Who is the worst QB left in the playoffs?

It seems that's who would give the Patriots the toughest game. Considering A.J. Feeley, Kyle Boller and Eli Manning looked like All-Pros and gave the Pats the most trouble during the regular season, we should be more worried Phillip Rivers than the real Manning

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Phillip Rivers

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

PR's mobility, or lack thereof, makes me cringe. Drew Bledsoe looked faster.

Todd Collins?

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Another vote for Philip Rivers.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

rhodeislandpatsfan said:

It seems that's who would give the Patriots the toughest game. Considering A.J. Feeley, Kyle Boller and Eli Manning looked like All-Pros and gave the Pats the most trouble during the regular season, we should be more worried Phillip Rivers than the real Manning

Click to expand...

Rivers. He dumps it to Gates because he can't read how things are setting up. The fact that he's a young punk, trash talking whiner makes me happy that he sucks so bad.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Bostonian1962 said:

Rivers. He dumps it to Gates because he can't read how things are setting up. The fact that he's a young punk, trash talking whiner makes me happy that he sucks so bad.

Click to expand...

Rivers was pretty accurate from about the second quarter on yesterday. Of course, it was Oakland...Announcers pointed out if you force him to his left, he gets pretty helpless because of his gimpy left knee. Rivers is still better than Young/Collins though, I think.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Rivers gets frustrated easily, and when he gets frustrated or the least bit riled, he plays like crap.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

There are weaker QBs than Rivers. But for our purposes, it's Rivers. He has the maturity of an 8-year-old. I have a good friend who is die hard Bolts fan and he even admits Rivers can't take them all the way.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Ohhhhh. That's a tough one. Rivers or Young. Rivers is terrible, but lets not forget how much Vince Young blows.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Rivers is the sorriest QB in the league!

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Brady. He can't throw further than 65 yards.

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Did you guys forget that the Titans made the playoffs? Rivers is bad, but Vince Young is bottom 10 in the league (in a REAL bad time for the league QB-wise).

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Vince is bad but his legs catapolte him ahead of Rivers.

Who would you pick for your franchise?

Re: Who is the worst QB left in the play-offs?

Almost anybody above Young. But then again, I'm a huge fan of watching Brady and Manning and the cerebral approach to the game. Not a dumb rock like Young.

Vince Young closely followed by Rivers though.

1) God Brady
2) Manning
3) Roethlisberger
4) Garrard
5) Young
6) Rivers

1) Romo
2) Favre
3) Hasselbeck
4) Garcia
5) Collins (Jumping to conclusions? Maybe, but he's been good...)
6) Manning

It's really tough to pick between Rivers and Eli. I'd have to pick Eli though, Rivers has at least done something in the regular season, even if it wasn't he himself who did it at least he managed those games well enough to win 14 last year.

NovaScotiaPatsFan said:

It's really tough to pick between Rivers and Eli. I'd have to pick Eli though, Rivers has at least done something in the regular season, even if it wasn't he himself who did it at least he managed those games well enough to win 14 last year.

Click to expand...

Rivers is 25-7 as a starting QB. A lot of teams would take those numbers.

Eli Manning says hello. I think his game against us was an abberration. These teams that played us when the game didn't mean anything to them were at a distinct advantage when it came to strategy. Could wing it without any fear of the consequences. Now, you go home if you lose. We've been playing with that mentality all year. Me thinks the Bucs force 3-4 turnovers and send Eli home.

sanvara said:

Rivers is 25-7 as a starting QB. A lot of teams would take those numbers.

Click to expand...

How many would take him over Drew Brees as the Chargers did? Not many.