PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Edelman > Welker


Status
Not open for further replies.
I often agree with your posts but we are FANS after all... So why is it stupid for us to compare two similar players that we've watched over the last few years? As long as no one is trolling I don't see why we can't have a discussion about it.
Because this is about the 6th time a Edelman/Welker thread has been made. It got old after the first 3.
 
The good news is we don't need to compare them because we had the benefit of having each on our team.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: PP2
I think both were great, just Welker cost us few games...and the big one drop...

Other than that Welker somewhat benefited from the system since we had Moss on our team that was consistently drawing double coverage's.

I like our current team, plus Martin is becoming really good in this system, he may even replace Amendola if Danny decides to walk and go after a bigger contract this off-season.
I think thats the reason the Pats gave Martin this extension.
Obviously I want to keep this group together.
 
People really over magnify Wes' drop in SB 46. They never mention his 11 catch 103 yard performance in SB 42.
 
I'll certainly take Edleman over Welker.

But, you have to appreciate how quickly Welker got in sync with TB. it was amazing that he could come in here in within the same year be on the same page as Brady 95%+ of the time.

Neither player had that quit button and had loads on intensity. Welker kinda shot his way out with the contracts and Edleman is certainly our guy now (and I couldn't be happier). Edleman has that same intensity as TB and can give nothing less than 100% for each step/rep/play/practice/game/season...
 
during Welker's last year with the Pats, my son and I were having a discussion about keeping Welker. Edelman wasn't seeing much of the field. But I told him Edelman was bigger (not by much), stronger, and faster and if ever got the chance would prove to be better than Welker. It's really nice to hear you son say "You were right Dad"!!
 
Edelman should be nicknamed Edel"THE"man. The guy is extremely reliable and unlike Welker adds swagger to this team by just being on the field.
He dropped 3 passes. Just injecting a little reality here. That said Edelperson is amazing.
 
Dear God,

Not this stupidity again.

I know it, there are still some who would take Welker over Edelman? Idiots!*


*I used to be one of the most vocal for re signing Welker but Edelman is the better player.
 
Last edited:
Welker was a tremendous player here and his numbers put him just below HOF status... that being said he had 2 drops here that cost the TEAM possible wins. It's human nature as a fan to hold that against him but unfortunately for him fans for the most part fans root for the TEAM. I'll take the guy who has the stones to make the play when it matters and for my money Edelman is more that guy than Welker. Just one fans opinion.
 
Last edited:
Both receivers are warriors.
So true. I loved Welker, he was such a warrior, that missed pass in the SB was so heartbreaking. He catches that and we have 5 SB wins and he's a Pat's immortal. Still a Pat's legend in my mind.

Edelman is so like Welker, but just has that extra gear speed wise. On punt returns for instance, once he got past you he was gone. No catching him. Welker was usually always caught from behind. But man, they are so alike, so shifty and great route runners. I give Edelman a slight edge because he came up HUGE in the SB.

We've been so lucky in the slot position, from Brown to a Branch to Welker to Edelman, 4 of Brady's all time favorite receivers, with 3 of them being excellent punt returners.
 
When the Welker debate was going on my belief was that the most important piece Brady needs to be successful is a receiver who can literally get open instantly and repeatedly and Seller was that guy, and depriving Brady of that piece would stop drives and force Brady to take a serious beating, and I still believe that to be the case. And while I liked Edelman he had issues with durability and his hand weren't as good as Welkers. I thought Belichick was making a big mistake letting him walk, especially to Denver. I was happy however that they signed Amendola because he could give them the quick hitting receiver Brady thrives with. I was also happy that Edelman returned because he would give them insurance if Amendola were injured, what I didn't realize was just how good a player Edelman was going to turn himself and when Amendola tie his groin in Buffalo it gave Edelman his chance and since that day Edelman has become one of the best players in football and one of the most important players in the league. Regardless of the numbers Edelman has become a better player than Welker was, he's tougher than Welker, and that's saying something because Welker was tough tough player, but he also brings a dimension with his explosiveness that Welker never really had, and while Welker was a tough guy to cover Edelman cannot be covered with one guy. As Ninkovich said yesterday Edelman has "the heart of a lion, " and that can't be be undersold, like Brady he simply won't be denied and that winter stink is a big reason they continue to pile up wins and are adding to their Championships. Welker may have had the edge in stats but if you are talking about each player at their best Edelman is a better overall player.
 
Wes Welker was a beast. Julian Edelman eats beasts.
 
People on this board either have short memories or chose to remember the worst
 
I appreciate them both.
 
People either have short memories or chose to remember the worst around here.

I don't know...I am still a huge WW fan, and I realize how great he was. The postseason misses never made me devalue his game. I just think Edelman is a better receiver, which I never thought I would say.
 
I don't know...I am still a huge WW fan, and I realize how great he was. The postseason misses never made me devalue his game. I just think Edelman is a better receiver, which I never thought I would say.

JE11 is a better athlete and better physical attributes no question.

Better receiver? I'm not ready to say that.
 
of course we are going to think jules is better because we are currently watching him. Welker was damn good too..why does it even matter?...I don't get posts like this.
 
I think people forget how dominating Welker was during his time here. Yes, Edelman has turned into the same type of player, and I think he'll be a career Patriots (so I like him better personally), but let's not pretend like Welker wasn't putting up HoF kind of numbers during his time here.
 
defense during Edelman's tenure > defense during Welker's tenure
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
MORSE: Patriots Draft Needs and Draft Related Info
Friday Patriots Notebook 4/19: News and Notes
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf’s Pre-Draft Press Conference 4/18/24
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/18: News and Notes
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/17: News and Notes
Back
Top