Aaron Rodgers is saddled by Mike McCarthy, possible the stupidest coach in the NFL, who barely lets him pass. Rodgers has 123 to Brady's 133 attempts this season and has played one more game.
I could see an argument that says Brady has been as good as Rodgers so far this season, but in general, Rodgers crushes Brady in every reasonable metric.
Also, I think that the rating systems are flawed but the simple fact is that Rodgers has been a more effective QB over the course of his career with an ANY/A of 7.79 to Brady's 6.99. And if you think your eyetest of watching Brady every single week and watching Rodgers ~sometimes is a more reliable, less biased approach then lol at you.
Also feel free to critique ANY/A if you can rather than just giving
emotional responses or Deus-esque one-liners, it basically just tells you who does better when asked to throw:
"
ANY/A. adjusted net yards per passing attempt: (pass yards + 20*(pass TD) - 45*(interceptions thrown) - sack yards)/(passing attempts + sacks). Note that we are now using 20 yards per TD instead of 10, because of research by Chase Stuart
at the p-f-r blog."
People here always want to (rightfully) trumpet Belichick as the best coach ever and then explain away Brady's statistical shortcomings to Manning and Rodgers with team accomplishments and bah humbug eyetest over stats comments, but it's not really a reasonable debate except on First Take or whatever