PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Brady vs. Montana


Status
Not open for further replies.

fnordcircle

The poster who James White said inspires him.
PatsFans.com Supporter
Joined
Sep 10, 2006
Messages
16,238
Reaction score
33,794
Do you think it was more probable than not that Montana was generally aware that his #1 receiver was cheating?
 
What is your point? The point of this thread??
 
Everyone in the NFL cheats or gets help from people who cheat on a given play.

It is just people drinking hater-ade. 20 years from now people will care about as much as they do about any of the past "scandals".
 
Tainted.
 
What is your point? The point of this thread??

Well, PatsGuy. Tom Brady is a player in the National Football League. He currently plays for the New England Patriots. The New England Patriots have won a lot of games including some Super Bowls. This has lead to some people questioning where Tom Brady's ranking against all-time great QBs might be. While there is no true consensus I feel it is fair to say that the QB who has the most folks calling him the greatest of all time would be Joseph Montana, aka Joe Montana.

Now, Joe Montana no longer plays the sport of football in the National Football League. But he did a few decades back. During his time his team won a lot of games and even some Super Bowls. This is important information, we'll come back to it shortly.

Recent events, and some not so recent, have resulted in Tom Brady being unfairly cast as a cheater by those with an axe to grind or, at the very least a desire to see his legacy tainted. Specifically a situation that occurred in 2007 where the Patriots were filming defensive signals, out in the open, from the wrong location. This past year there was a situation involving claims that the Patriots intentionally deflated footballs.

Here's where it gets interesting - at the height of this Jerry Rice made some statements. Jerry Rice, you may or may not be aware, is considered the greatest WR of all time and he played with Joe Montana. Please refer to paragraph 2 for more information on Joe Montana. These comments were less than supportive of Tom Brady. However, it was during this time that previous statements Mr. Rice had made about using illegal substances on his gloves to better help catch the ball came to light.

So, the point of this thread, during this the busiest time of the season when posting space is at a premium, would be to question whether or not Joe Montana might have been aware that he was playing with a cheater and, as a result, receiving a direct benefit. And, if so, why that would not be considered a taint against his legacy but the claims of ball deflating on behalf of the Patriots would be.
 
Well, PatsGuy. Tom Brady is a player in the National Football League. He currently plays for the New England Patriots. The New England Patriots have won a lot of games including some Super Bowls. This has lead to some people questioning where Tom Brady's ranking against all-time great QBs might be. While there is no true consensus I feel it is fair to say that the QB who has the most folks calling him the greatest of all time would be Joseph Montana, aka Joe Montana.

Now, Joe Montana no longer plays the sport of football in the National Football League. But he did a few decades back. During his time his team won a lot of games and even some Super Bowls. This is important information, we'll come back to it shortly.

Recent events, and some not so recent, have resulted in Tom Brady being unfairly cast as a cheater by those with an axe to grind or, at the very least a desire to see his legacy tainted. Specifically a situation that occurred in 2007 where the Patriots were filming defensive signals, out in the open, from the wrong location. This past year there was a situation involving claims that the Patriots intentionally deflated footballs.

Here's where it gets interesting - at the height of this Jerry Rice made some statements. Jerry Rice, you may or may not be aware, is considered the greatest WR of all time and he played with Joe Montana. Please refer to paragraph 2 for more information on Joe Montana. These comments were less than supportive of Tom Brady. However, it was during this time that previous statements Mr. Rice had made about using illegal substances on his gloves to better help catch the ball came to light.

So, the point of this thread, during this the busiest time of the season when posting space is at a premium, would be to question whether or not Joe Montana might have been aware that he was playing with a cheater and, as a result, receiving a direct benefit. And, if so, why that would not be considered a taint against his legacy but the claims of ball deflating on behalf of the Patriots would be.

Good points.

One more. Jerry Rice struggled catching the ball until he started cheating in his second year.
 
Well, PatsGuy. Tom Brady is a player in the National Football League. He currently plays for the New England Patriots. The New England Patriots have won a lot of games including some Super Bowls. This has lead to some people questioning where Tom Brady's ranking against all-time great QBs might be. While there is no true consensus I feel it is fair to say that the QB who has the most folks calling him the greatest of all time would be Joseph Montana, aka Joe Montana.

Now, Joe Montana no longer plays the sport of football in the National Football League. But he did a few decades back. During his time his team won a lot of games and even some Super Bowls. This is important information, we'll come back to it shortly.

Recent events, and some not so recent, have resulted in Tom Brady being unfairly cast as a cheater by those with an axe to grind or, at the very least a desire to see his legacy tainted. Specifically a situation that occurred in 2007 where the Patriots were filming defensive signals, out in the open, from the wrong location. This past year there was a situation involving claims that the Patriots intentionally deflated footballs.

Here's where it gets interesting - at the height of this Jerry Rice made some statements. Jerry Rice, you may or may not be aware, is considered the greatest WR of all time and he played with Joe Montana. Please refer to paragraph 2 for more information on Joe Montana. These comments were less than supportive of Tom Brady. However, it was during this time that previous statements Mr. Rice had made about using illegal substances on his gloves to better help catch the ball came to light.

So, the point of this thread, during this the busiest time of the season when posting space is at a premium, would be to question whether or not Joe Montana might have been aware that he was playing with a cheater and, as a result, receiving a direct benefit. And, if so, why that would not be considered a taint against his legacy but the claims of ball deflating on behalf of the Patriots would be.
Actually I did know what your point was but was waiting for you to say it.
Many on this board have become obssessed with deflation PSI that it permeates many of the threads. it's like a breath of fresh air when a football Only related thread comes up. Unfortunately it will only get worse when the appeal is broadcast.
 
Actually I did know what your point was but was waiting for you to say it.

But sir, your post suggested you didn't understand. I'm so confused!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/25: News and Notes
Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/24: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
Back
Top