NFLPA says Tom Brady appeal continues, despite Kraft’s decision

mgteich · May 19, 2015

TheBostonStraggler said:
If Brady's sole fight is to get a reduction in penalty, while not nothing, this day is even more depressing than before.
Look, there was someone who first challenged the commissioner's punishment decision. There is someone who won a decision. I don't know if any player has overturned guilt, however, if not there always can be a first.
Anything less than Brady getting this in front of a judge/neutral third party to decide guilt will be extremely disappointing.

The NFLPA will go to court to fight for an independent arbiter.

Jlaff · May 19, 2015

SVN said:
If goodell allows a neutral arbitrator and he only reduced 2 games, can brady still go to court ?

My 3L instincts say - without a doubt. People appeal those decisions all the time.

Rob0729 · May 19, 2015

mgteich said:
And you'd have made the wrong legal decision. The time to go to court is when the appeals under the CBA are exhausted. If Goodell names himself arbiter, the NFLPA will be in court. If the sentence is upheld, the NFLPA will be in court.

There is nothing to fight at the moment. As you say, if the suspension is removed, there is nothing to fight except for a defamation suit. That is absolutely true.

Actually someone with legal experience covered this before. The NFLPA and Brady could go to court now to try to remove Goodell as arbitrator. Because they are arguing that the Troy Vincent punishment and Goodell ruling over it violates the rules of the CBA, they can circumvent the exhaustion of all options.

mgteich · May 19, 2015

Rob0729 said:
Actually someone with legal experience covered this before. The NFLPA and Brady could go to court now to try to remove Goodell as arbitrator. Because they are arguing that the Troy Vincent punishment and Goodell ruling over it violates the rules of the CBA, they can circumvent the exhaustion of all options.

We needn't argue.

The NFLPA has made it clear that it will not step into an appeal with Goodell as arbiter, without a court fight first.

flasox27 · May 19, 2015

I hope the NFLPA destroys the NFL anti trust provision which the gutless coward and his fellow owners want to protect. It would serve him right for crapping on his fans.

SVN · May 19, 2015

Rob0729 said:
If I am Brady and the NFLPA, I am going to court now. I still think Kraft and Goodell have a deal about Brady and if Goodell overturns the suspension, he can do so without exonerating Brady and Brady will have nothing to fight in court other than a defamation suit.

So you think if goodell appoints an independent arbitrator who only reduced the suspension to 2 or 1 games then Brady can't go to court to fight this ? We have to hope Brady is not part of this deal between goodell and kraft .

IcyPatriot · May 19, 2015

I want Kraft to have nothing to do with Brady's appeal ... nothing.

Tom will clear himself with dignity on his own.

Peachhead · May 19, 2015

Real American Hero said:
I'd like to believe that this goes full bore resulting in Brady's name being cleared and after that happens the NFL is forced to reconsider the penalties on the Pats because no crime was committed.

I hate to be a negative nancy to a fellow fan. Especially after the day we've all had. But if Brady's suspension ends up in court it's gonna take a loooooooong time. He may get an injunction that allows him to say on the field till the whole thing is settled. But I'd be absolutely astounded if a court case regarding this is over by next draft. By the time it's all done there might not be many outstanding penalties left to reconsider.

RIpats88 · May 20, 2015

Well if theres a silver lining in any of this brady will not miss a single game this season imo...because he will fight until he is exonerated.

If the nflpa got ray rice, peterson, saints players suspensions thrown out brady should be a slam dunk.

Screw the #1 pick...I want hof brady out there to go after #5 and show the haters

signbabybrady · May 20, 2015

Brady wins #5 and retires but still refuses to drop his court case! Sues Kraft and owns the team in 2016. One can dream right.

NFLPA says Tom Brady appeal continues, despite Kraft’s decision

mgteich

PatsFans.com Veteran

Jlaff

Early Bird Specials

Rob0729

PatsFans.com Supporter

mgteich

PatsFans.com Veteran

flasox27

In the Starting Line-Up

SVN

PatsFans.com Retired Jersey Club

IcyPatriot

Wall of Fame

Peachhead

PatsFans.com Supporter

RIpats88

Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract

signbabybrady

Pro Bowl Player

Similar threads