PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Tom Brady is still the #1 QB in the league.


Status
Not open for further replies.

PATS16N0

Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract
Joined
Jan 19, 2012
Messages
6,073
Reaction score
7,073
May as well start from the top. Anyone remember this little gem?


"A football team, somewhere in New England..."
I guess now everybody knows where that somewhere is, and from where we are now, it's hard to imagine going to my first football game as a kid, and sitting in those bleachers that were no better than the ones I later saw on my High School field, having no idea what was going on. To put `somewhere in New England` on the map, it took Tom Brady, 3 Superbowl trophies, and rewriting the history of everything that was apparently supposed to be.

The Greatest show on turf.
You're backed up and have to play for overtime.
Peyton the Chosen One
The Steeler Dynasty that never was.
"He'll never be the same when he returns from his ACL"
The 5-3 2011 Patriots are done.
Denver just has too many weapons.
No Longer a Top 5 QB
Tom is in decline
They're just not good anymore
Tom Brady will never reach another Superbowl.

And so here we are.

So let's get to it.

Nobody else in this league, or even the HISTORY of this league, would have been able to come back from two 14 point deficits to beat that Ravens team in the plays offs. Not in that game. Not in any other. Not in the urgency and pressure of the single elimination post-season.

Why are we so sure?

Because no one ever has.

Not Rodgers, not Brees, not Peyton.

Not Montana, not Elway, not Marino.

Nobody.

This isn't the regular season. This is the playoffs, and all of them, every single one, would of folded like a cheap tent at worst, or came up short, walking off the field in defeat, their season over, at best.

No running the football, spotty protection from the offensive line, spotty performance by the defense, no attempt to even pretend to be anything other than one dimensional, passing through the air.

Just Tom Brady throwing to his boys.

Show me someone who claims another could do what Tom does, and I'll show you someone who is full of crap. Like Denver on the sidelines, getting their asses kicked in the Superbowl, with one of their coaches telling their team, "We can come back. We've already seen it before this year, against us, in New England."

There's only one problem, Coach.

Tom Brady is not your quarterback.

Peyton would of cracked, wilted, and went home last night. Brees would of fell to pieces. Rodgers would of started getting sacked all over the place.

Aaron Rodgers, for all his talent, and all his ability, is Mr. Irrelevant in the 4th quarter of football games that are of the variety in which Tom Brady proves he is still the man. For everything this man is, for all his attributes and assets as an NFL quarterback, he no Tom Brady.

Drew Brees? I've heard of her, but she doesn't seem to be around when it matters very often. He was sitting at home last night watching Cam Newton and his 7-8-1 Panthers play awful football against the Seahawks.

Peyton? With all due respect to him, he doesn't deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as our quarterback.

That's the difference between Tom Brady intangibles and all the other guys.

Compared to Tom Brady, that's really all they are. Throw them all in a category together. They're all just "the other guys." Media darlings for week #6, and hot commodities for fantasy football, an imaginary game.

The Steelers, the Colts, the Chargers, the Jets, the Broncos, the Ravens
Since 2001, all these teams have come and gone, risen up to challenge us as our rivals, and fallen back into irrelevancy. Each has come thinking they were New England's equal, just like the one before them, and each has fallen back into mediocrity, just like the one before them.

Wide receivers come, wide receivers go. Offensive linemen come, offensive linemen go. Some years we've had a defense, sometimes we haven't. It just never seems to matter.

Tom Brady remains.

Still the best quarterback in the National Football League, and the greatest quarterback there ever was.

People have their narratives, but who has the time?
The New England Patriots, in the Tom Brady era, are on to AFC Championship game number nine.
 
What drives me crazy about the Brady detractors is that they claim Brady's AFCC and Super Bowl losses somehow tarnish his record.

So, Montana is 4 - 0 in Super Bowl play. Great. What people neglect to mention is that Montana lost in the wild card round for 3 straight years, or that Montana's '49ers only managed to score a combined total of 19 points in 3 playoff losses to the Giants, or that in 1987, Montana's 13-2 '49ers lost to some guy named Wade Wilson and his 8-7 Vikings.

Brady has advanced deeper into the playoffs more often and more consistently than any other QB who has ever played the game. He is unfairly criticized for his losses because they came on a bigger stage. The fact that he has led his teams to this stage as often as he has is astounding. To say he is a lesser QB that Montana because his losses came in the AFCC and Super Bowl instead of the wild card round is illogical and statistically bogus.

Some other statistical nuggets proving the GOATness of Tom Brady:
-Brady's Patriots are the only team under the current playoff format to earn a 1st round bye for 5 years in a row.
-Brady's Patriots are one of only 6 teams to appear in 4 consecutive conference championship games, joining Dallas and Oakland in the 70's, Buffalo and Dallas in the early 90's, and Philly a decade ago.
-Brady's all time ranks in the playoffs: wins (#1), passing yards (#1), passing TDs (#1), passer rating (#14), pass attempts (#1), comebacks (#2t), game winning drives (#1).
 
What drives me crazy about the Brady detractors is that they claim Brady's AFCC and Super Bowl losses somehow tarnish his record.

So, Montana is 4 - 0 in Super Bowl play. Great. What people neglect to mention is that Montana lost in the wild card round for 3 straight years, or that Montana's '49ers only managed to score a combined total of 19 points in 3 playoff losses to the Giants, or that in 1987, Montana's 13-2 '49ers lost to some guy named Wade Wilson and his 8-7 Vikings.

Brady has advanced deeper into the playoffs more often and more consistently than any other QB who has ever played the game. He is unfairly criticized for his losses because they came on a bigger stage. The fact that he has led his teams to this stage as often as he has is astounding. To say he is a lesser QB that Montana because his losses came in the AFCC and Super Bowl instead of the wild card round is illogical and statistically bogus.

Some other statistical nuggets proving the GOATness of Tom Brady:
-Brady's Patriots are the only team under the current playoff format to earn a 1st round bye for 5 years in a row.
-Brady's Patriots are one of only 6 teams to appear in 4 consecutive conference championship games, joining Dallas and Oakland in the 70's, Buffalo and Dallas in the early 90's, and Philly a decade ago.
-Brady's all time ranks in the playoffs: wins (#1), passing yards (#1), passing TDs (#1), passer rating (#14), pass attempts (#1), comebacks (#2t), game winning drives (#1).

Yes. This. Exactly.

Waiting for all the "The Patriots renegotiated to release Tom," "Tom in decline," "start Jimmy Nobody," and "Rodgers is #1" crowd to come out and play but I don't think they have much to say today.
 
I think Bradys will to win is very underrated part of his game. I strongly believe no other QB could've led us back from two TD deficit twice in a postseason game other than him. His will to win is contagious and you can tell the team woke up when he got fired up in the first TD he scored yesterday.
 
I think Bradys will to win is very underrated part of his game. I strongly believe no other QB could've led us back from two TD deficit twice in a postseason game other than him. His will to win is contagious and you can tell the team woke up when he got fired up in the first TD he scored yesterday.

The fact that no QB in NFL postseason history ever has lends that belief a lot of credibility. lol
 
"Tom Brady the #1 QB in the league"

Did someone doubt this?
 
May as well start from the top. Anyone remember this little gem?


"A football team, somewhere in New England..."
I guess now everybody knows where that somewhere is, and from where we are now, it's hard to imagine going to my first football game as a kid, and sitting in those bleachers that were no better than the ones I later saw on my High School field, having no idea what was going on. To put `somewhere in New England` on the map, it took Tom Brady, 3 Superbowl trophies, and rewriting the history of everything that was apparently supposed to be.

The Greatest show on turf.
You're backed up and have to play for overtime.
Peyton the Chosen One
The Steeler Dynasty that never was.
"He'll never be the same when he returns from his ACL"
The 5-3 2011 Patriots are done.
Denver just has too many weapons.
No Longer a Top 5 QB
Tom is in decline
They're just not good anymore
Tom Brady will never reach another Superbowl.

And so here we are.

So let's get to it.

Nobody else in this league, or even the HISTORY of this league, would have been able to come back from two 14 point deficits to beat that Ravens team in the plays offs. Not in that game. Not in any other. Not in the urgency and pressure of the single elimination post-season.

Why are we so sure?

Because no one ever has.

Not Rodgers, not Brees, not Peyton.

Not Montana, not Elway, not Marino.

Nobody.

This isn't the regular season. This is the playoffs, and all of them, every single one, would of folded like a cheap tent at worst, or came up short, walking off the field in defeat, their season over, at best.

No running the football, spotty protection from the offensive line, spotty performance by the defense, no attempt to even pretend to be anything other than one dimensional, passing through the air.

Just Tom Brady throwing to his boys.

Show me someone who claims another could do what Tom does, and I'll show you someone who is full of crap. Like Denver on the sidelines, getting their asses kicked in the Superbowl, with one of their coaches telling their team, "We can come back. We've already seen it before this year, against us, in New England."

There's only one problem, Coach.

Tom Brady is not your quarterback.

Peyton would of cracked, wilted, and went home last night. Brees would of fell to pieces. Rodgers would of started getting sacked all over the place.

Aaron Rodgers, for all his talent, and all his ability, is Mr. Irrelevant in the 4th quarter of football games that are of the variety in which Tom Brady proves he is still the man. For everything this man is, for all his attributes and assets as an NFL quarterback, he no Tom Brady.

Drew Brees? I've heard of her, but she doesn't seem to be around when it matters very often. He was sitting at home last night watching Cam Newton and his 7-8-1 Panthers play awful football against the Seahawks.

Peyton? With all due respect to him, he doesn't deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as our quarterback.

That's the difference between Tom Brady intangibles and all the other guys.

Compared to Tom Brady, that's really all they are. Throw them all in a category together. They're all just "the other guys." Media darlings for week #6, and hot commodities for fantasy football, an imaginary game.

The Steelers, the Colts, the Chargers, the Jets, the Broncos, the Ravens
Since 2001, all these teams have come and gone, risen up to challenge us as our rivals, and fallen back into irrelevancy. Each has come thinking they were New England's equal, just like the one before them, and each has fallen back into mediocrity, just like the one before them.

Wide receivers come, wide receivers go. Offensive linemen come, offensive linemen go. Some years we've had a defense, sometimes we haven't. It just never seems to matter.

Tom Brady remains.

Still the best quarterback in the National Football League, and the greatest quarterback there ever was.

People have their narratives, but who has the time?
The New England Patriots, in the Tom Brady era, are on to AFC Championship game number nine.


I agree and think t is funny that to find QBs worthy of mentioning with him you have to go deep in history and even then they are only arguably on par.
 
What drives me crazy about the Brady detractors is that they claim Brady's AFCC and Super Bowl losses somehow tarnish his record.

So, Montana is 4 - 0 in Super Bowl play. Great. What people neglect to mention is that Montana lost in the wild card round for 3 straight years, or that Montana's '49ers only managed to score a combined total of 19 points in 3 playoff losses to the Giants, or that in 1987, Montana's 13-2 '49ers lost to some guy named Wade Wilson and his 8-7 Vikings.

Brady has advanced deeper into the playoffs more often and more consistently than any other QB who has ever played the game. He is unfairly criticized for his losses because they came on a bigger stage. The fact that he has led his teams to this stage as often as he has is astounding. To say he is a lesser QB that Montana because his losses came in the AFCC and Super Bowl instead of the wild card round is illogical and statistically bogus.

Some other statistical nuggets proving the GOATness of Tom Brady:
-Brady's Patriots are the only team under the current playoff format to earn a 1st round bye for 5 years in a row.
-Brady's Patriots are one of only 6 teams to appear in 4 consecutive conference championship games, joining Dallas and Oakland in the 70's, Buffalo and Dallas in the early 90's, and Philly a decade ago.
-Brady's all time ranks in the playoffs: wins (#1), passing yards (#1), passing TDs (#1), passer rating (#14), pass attempts (#1), comebacks (#2t), game winning drives (#1).

But at the end of the day. Montana is still 4-0 in super bowls and has never thrown and int in a Super Bowl. Brady needs one more to jump him. Just my opinion
 
"Tom Brady the #1 QB in the league"

Did someone doubt this?

Yes, many, he's in decline, didn't you hear? Rodgers is #1 because ESPN said so, we renegotiated Brady's contract to release him, and Belichick `drafted JAG to prepare to move on`
 
Montana was great, but he existed in a period where there was no salary cap and during that time San Francisco amassed, kept great talent and money was no object.. if someone moved on they would just bring in a replacement..

IMO it is like comparing raisins to grapefruit..
 
Joe Montana was an elite game manager owning Superbowls when the AFC was pathetic. AFC didn't win a single Superbowl in the pre-Salary cap era for 12 or 13 years in a row.

That isn't a knock against the great Joe Montana, but nostalgia has a way off overly romanticizing things.

#1 Tom Brady > #2 Joe Montana

Tom Brady isn't a game manager. He's a freaking Terminator.
 
Noting that a QB like Flacco (who I will admit I like as a QB) is going to cost the Ravens $28.5 million on their cap in 2016 makes me appreciate Brady's willingness to accept a hometown discount

We can gripe about whether they give Brady enough targets but the team is still given the flexibility to bring in difference makers like Revis when Tom gives them that added flexibility by not demanding top dollar
 
Noting that a QB like Flacco (who I will admit I like as a QB) is going to cost the Ravens $28.5 million on their cap in 2016 makes me appreciate Brady's willingness to accept a hometown discount

We can gripe about whether they give Brady enough targets but the team is still given the flexibility to bring in difference makers like Revis when Tom gives them that added flexibility by not demanding top dollar

This offense is on fire now. Brady and the coaches have really done a masterful job of incorporating everyone into the offense this season. Lafell has been balling, Amendola is now going beast mode.

I'm fine with our offensive situation

And yes, the GOAT for 8 M a year is a discount that makes anyone theorizing we're about to get rid of him seem very confused.
 
Who loved how Tom looked in the pocket yesterday? He was juking, jiving, spinning, twisting, turning, AND making throws amidst all of it.

Something is different about this Tom Brady. Last year I think on a lot of these plays he would of taken the `live to fight another day` strategy and covered up.

If I can put on my credential-less psychology hat for a moment, I think Tom became overly protective of himself after his ACL injury, fearing above anything else the season ending injury.

This year he isn't giving up on any plays. There was one play last night that was just unbelievable, he had guys all over him, and he hung tough and delivered a laser with pass rushers everywhere, inches away.

Declining? More like getting better. He looked like 2007 Tom Terrific last night
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/24: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
MORSE: Patriots Draft Needs and Draft Related Info
Back
Top