- Joined
- Mar 21, 2006
- Messages
- 7,939
- Reaction score
- 16,946
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Had a little time between meetings.
I went to Pro Football Reference.com and got a total of 55 vs 59, but I wasn't being very precise:
Buffalo: six different HC's including "interims," 13 different QB's listed as starting a game (19 total)
Miami: seven different HC's including "interims," 16 different QB's listed as starting a game (23 total)
New Jersey: three different HC's, 10 different QB's listed as starting a game (13 total).
Amazing, especially in Miami.
So true. Dolphins go from the Marino era to the situation you outlined above.
A great QB often makes a 'great' coach, the opposite usually isn't true but truly great coaches can usually find an above-average QB within a few seasons.
The most interesting situation, to me, is in NY. Miami had Marino for about 18 seasons, before that Griese. They've developed some marginal talent--Fielder and Tannehill--they've just never hit on the 'one'. The Bills had Kelly for over a decade, before him Ferguson was at least stability even if he wasn't good (I was too young/not born during his time, but at least going by team record it doesn't appear he was anything special). Then there's NY. Going all the way back to Namath they've bounced from QB to QB, the longest stretches were by immortals like Ken O'Brien and Rich Todd. We're talking forty years since Namath, and they haven't been able to hit on a single above-average QB in that entire time. It's mind-boggling, really.
Basically agree, but I'd probably quibble that Pennington was "above average" (career Pass Rating of 90.1 and a winning record). He also had Curtis Martin in the backfield with him and took his teams to the Playoffs three times. He was injured a lot towards the end of his career, but, IMHO, coaching was his real problem: Herm Edwards and the Rat.A great QB often makes a 'great' coach, the opposite usually isn't true but truly great coaches can usually find an above-average QB within a few seasons.
The most interesting situation, to me, is in NY. Miami had Marino for about 18 seasons, before that Griese. They've developed some marginal talent--Fielder and Tannehill--they've just never hit on the 'one'. The Bills had Kelly for over a decade, before him Ferguson was at least stability even if he wasn't good (I was too young/not born during his time, but at least going by team record it doesn't appear he was anything special). Then there's NY. Going all the way back to Namath they've bounced from QB to QB, the longest stretches were by immortals like Ken O'Brien and Rich Todd. We're talking forty years since Namath, and they haven't been able to hit on a single above-average QB in that entire time. It's mind-boggling, really.
We're talking forty years since Namath, and they haven't been able to hit on a single above-average QB in that entire time. It's mind-boggling, really.
is the consensus that Pennington was not even a little above average?
Basically agree, but I'd probably quibble that Pennington was "above average" (career Pass Rating of 90.1 and a winning record). He also had Curtis Martin in the backfield with him and took his teams to the Playoffs three times. He was injured a lot towards the end of his career, but, IMHO, coaching was his real problem: Herm Edwards and the Rat.