PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Could these 7' tall NBA Centers Be Successful in the NFL?


Danger Zone

In the Starting Line-Up
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
3,718
Reaction score
4,544
I dont follow basketball, but came across the news today that 7'5" Sim Bhullar signed recently with the Kings.

Sim Bhullar Becomes 1st NBA Player Of Indian Descent After Signing Deal With Kings | Huffington Post

Seven feet five inches tall.

360 lbs.

So WHY aren't these 7' tall players going into the NFL? Do coaches not want them? I see a lot of 6'8" and 6'9" players in the NFL, but that seems to be about the ceiling on the height of players making it as NFL players.

Still there must be a good reason for this. I mean a reason other than my American ethnocentric assumption that they don't play American football in India at any competitive level.. or I guess Europe for that matter.

The money doesn't seem THAT much better in the salary capped NBA. Kobe is "only" making 23 million.

And if Sim can play in the NBA I assume he is somewhat athletic and can catch a fade and at the very least jump for soft passes. Who could defend against that? What else would he need to do? Run 10 yards, turn around, jump for the pass.

I get why they might be poor blockers. But put someone 7'5" on the DL and I bet they could do nothing but bat down passes and still be as useful as the guys that get pressure on the quarterback.

No one ever claimed that 7'2" Jaws was super athletic, but he sure gave Bond at 6'1" a good run for his money. And I'd guess Edward Carl Gaedel wasn't super athletic either, but he sure was a great pinch-hitter in the Major League. :D

So maybe it comes down to how injury prone these super tall guys might actually be. Too much so to be a success in the NFL though? I suppose if given the choice between playing a violent contact sport for a few million less and I too might choose to make a career in the NBA instead.

Anyway, just some light-hearted musings.
 
Last edited:
they would lose all leverage remember in the trenches the lower man wins
 
You are wrong about the money. The money is a lot better in the NBA than in the NFL. How many NBA players make more than Jimmy Graham who is the highest paid TE in the league? Twenty? Thirty? More? I bet most of the NBA makes more than the average TE. Plus all the contracts are guaranteed in the NBA.

If I was a player who could play in either league, I would choose the NBA even though I am a huge NFL fam and casual at best as a NBA fan.
 
how-to-make-money-in-professional-sports-infographic-600x2156.png
 
They would get their legs destroyed being tackled. They would be useless outside of "run to the sideline x yards downfield," or "run to this spot in the endzone."

Edit: Not too mention, agility/change of direction is generally an issue for 7'+ humans with a body that would warrant an nfl look. Would Durant be a decent wr? Maybe. Would LeBron be a good te? Probably. Would they have longer, or as lucrative careers as they do in the NBA? Lol, hell no.
 
Last edited:
You are wrong about the money. The money is a lot better in the NBA than in the NFL. How many NBA players make more than Jimmy Graham who is the highest paid TE in the league? Twenty? Thirty? More? I bet most of the NBA makes more than the average TE. Plus all the contracts are guaranteed in the NBA.

If I was a player who could play in either league, I would choose the NBA even though I am a huge NFL fam and casual at best as a NBA fan.

That's the reason I'm guessing at as well.. with some added emphasis on player's choosing to make more money in a sport where you don't get tackled to the ground every time you touch the ball.

Still, Hasheem Thabeet is making 1.2 million and he is 7'3".

EDIT: @bigballas -Yup, could be as simple as that.
 
I dont follow basketball, but came across the news today that 7'5" Sim Bhullar signed recently with the Kings.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/08/16/sim-bhullar-nba-kings-indian-descent_n_5684787.html

Seven feet five inches tall.

360 lbs.

So WHY aren't these 7' tall players going into the NFL? Do coaches not want them? I see a lot of 6'8" and 6'9" players in the NFL, but that seems to be about the ceiling on the height of players making it as NFL players.

Still there must be a good reason for this. I mean a reason other than my American ethnocentric assumption that they don't play American football in India at any competitive level.. or I guess Europe for that matter.

The money doesnt seem THAT much better in the salary capped NBA. Kobe is "only" making 23 million.

And if Sim can play in the NBA I assume he is somewhat athletic and can catch a fade and at the very least jump for soft passes. Who could defend against that? What else would he need to do? Run 10 yards, turn around, jump for the pass.

I get why they might be poor blockers. But put someone 7'5" on the DL and I bet they could do nothing but bat down passes and still be as useful as the guys that get pressure on the quarterback.

Noone ever claimed that 7'2" Jaws was super athletic, but he sure gave Bond at 6'1" a good run for his money. And Im guess Edward Carl Gaedel wasn't super athletic either, but he sure was a great pinch-hitter in the Major League. :D

So maybe it comes down to how injury prone these super tall guys might actually be. Too much so to be a success in the NFL though? I suppose if given the choice between playing a violent contact sport for a few million less and I too might choose to make a career in the NBA instead.

Anyway, just some light-hearted musings.
I don't think they play too much football in India.
 
I dont follow basketball, but came across the news today that 7'5" Sim Bhullar signed recently with the Kings.

Sim Bhullar Becomes 1st NBA Player Of Indian Descent After Signing Deal With Kings | Huffington Post


Seven feet five inches tall.

360 lbs.

So WHY aren't these 7' tall players going into the NFL? Do coaches not want them? I see a lot of 6'8" and 6'9" players in the NFL, but that seems to be about the ceiling on the height of players making it as NFL players.

Still there must be a good reason for this. I mean a reason other than my American ethnocentric assumption that they don't play American football in India at any competitive level.. or I guess Europe for that matter.

The money doesn't seem THAT much better in the salary capped NBA. Kobe is "only" making 23 million.

And if Sim can play in the NBA I assume he is somewhat athletic and can catch a fade and at the very least jump for soft passes. Who could defend against that? What else would he need to do? Run 10 yards, turn around, jump for the pass.

I get why they might be poor blockers. But put someone 7'5" on the DL and I bet they could do nothing but bat down passes and still be as useful as the guys that get pressure on the quarterback.

No one ever claimed that 7'2" Jaws was super athletic, but he sure gave Bond at 6'1" a good run for his money. And I'd guess Edward Carl Gaedel wasn't super athletic either, but he sure was a great pinch-hitter in the Major League. :D

So maybe it comes down to how injury prone these super tall guys might actually be. Too much so to be a success in the NFL though? I suppose if given the choice between playing a violent contact sport for a few million less and I too might choose to make a career in the NBA instead.

Anyway, just some light-hearted musings.

You are completely right about the height for TEs or WRs but its hard to find a 7footer on DLine who can play. Now the 6'8 -6'9 TE or WR who is athletic and can run and is athletic as a 6'4 guy would put up incredible pass catching stats. Say a young Lebron or Carmelo or Garnett who is 6'9 or more and can run a 4.6 or better with great athleticism and jump ability would be tough to defend especially if he is an experienced pass catcher who played football in his and college. Thing is most of these guys played basketball and no football experience in college. The NFL contracts aren't guaranteed and only QBs make 20mil a yr or more. But if the next. Labron/Garnett/Carmelo or the 6'9 260 lb dude from the clippers plays TE or WR through college and the NFL shows a non QB could earn 20 mil a season then one of these 6'9 super athletic guys could end up snagging passes over defensive backs in the NFL. If Calvin Johnson were 6'9 what could he do. Or if Antonio Gates were a 6'9 forward instead of just nearly 6'4 and playing in the NFL what kind of stats would he post up. And there are players in the NBA with his athleticism running a 4.6-4.7 40 who are 6'9 or taller. If Garnett runs a 4.60-4.70, who could cover him at WR. The guy playing for Clippers 6'9 and 260 if he can run a 4.65-4.70 which is very realistic with the athleticism he shows, who could cover him playing TE.

However the NBA pays way more and it is easier to display their skills and standout playing basketball with 5 players. Football, at WR or TE they only get to showcase their skills when the ball is thrown his way and they can be doubled and bracketed which frustrates them. They usually don't have the patience with football to get to NFL where schemes and another standout WR will prevent that. They end up playing in the NBA. But if these guys only had patience and knew what they could do in the NFL at 6'10 245-250 running a 4.55 with elite athleticism at WR! NBA has several players with their height/skill scoring 25 a game. In the NFL they would be awesome, never played before talents while setting records
 
As noted above, few of the guys with an unstoppable height mismatch could take the pounding long enough to contribute much. BB has also noted that most basketball players who otherwise would seem to be well-suited to switch to football lack the speed you want even from a TE.

And here's an example -- Glen "Big Baby" Davis. He had the body and strength to succeed as a TE. He played hoops because he wanted to. But if we look at his career earnings, he had some years well over $5 million, so he would have had to be a lot better at football than he was at basketball to duplicate that in the NFL.
 
lack of leverage, agility, speed.....there are exceptions like lebron, probably......
 


Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
MORSE: Patriots Draft Needs and Draft Related Info
Friday Patriots Notebook 4/19: News and Notes
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf’s Pre-Draft Press Conference 4/18/24
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/18: News and Notes
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/17: News and Notes
Back
Top