Grade Brady's performance in this past AFC Championship Game

In addition to checking out different links that gave out report cards, I asked this question to a couple of writers and analysts (I specifically asked if they'd give Brady a C for his performance, which I thought sounded about right). Here are the results I got:

Field Yates: C
Christopher Price: C
Oliver Thomas: C
USA Today: C
Andy Gresh: C
Bleacher Report writer: C-

As mentioned before, I gave Brady a C. What grade would you give Brady for that performance?

Are we grading on a Brady scale or an average starting QB scale? He played about as well as you'd expect him to play given the surrounding cast, which I guess equates to a C on the Brady scale. Put a worse QB in his position and it could have gotten really ugly.

Just what we need......

A "Grade Brady" thread.

A lot better than it would have been if we had played Seattle with that surrounding cast on both sides of the ball.

No disrespect but what does grading something that happened last season really accomplish?

Four thumbs down

I grade pass/fail. They lost. All fail. Yes it is tough.