- Joined
- Jan 22, 2005
- Messages
- 30,994
- Reaction score
- 15,552
This. Either I haven't been paying much attention to Mesko, or Allen can actually kick coffin corners. Against the Giants he hit the sidelines at the 7 and 10, and his third was a fair catch close to the sideline around the 14.
Mesko, statistically, was mediocre to bad last season in yards per punt and net yards (28th and 24th, respectively). The thing he was great at was limiting return yards (154 on 60 total punts; 2nd in the league). Like you said (8 yards on 5 punts), Allen looks like he can match that. I think it's a good move, as long as we have a good holder... which is what I'm worried most about.
I just rewatched the Giants game and Mesko was the only holder.
The holding has me nervous.
In any case, punting averages are among the most misleading statistics in sports. It's not like KOs where you have an obvious comparison point (e.g., there's a big difference between punting from your own 20 and your own 49).
And, FWIW, Football Outsiders ranked the Pats' punting team as, on the whole, a net positive for the team (11th overall).