Rank your top 10 QB's in the league today.

1.Brady
2.Rodgers
3.Brees
4.E. Manning
5.Roethlisberger
6.P. Manning
7.Stafford
8.Rivers
9.Newton
10.Ryan


Honorable mentions: Romo, Vick, Flacco, Schaub, Cutler.

1.Brady
2.Rodgers
3.Brees
4.Roethlisberger
5.P. Manning
6.E. Manning
7.Stafford
8.Rivers
9.Romo
10.Ryan

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. P. Manning
4. Brees
5. E. Manning
6. Stafford
7. Rapistburgler
8. Rivers
9. Newton
10. Ryan

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
4. P. Manning
5. E. Manning
6. Roethlisberger
7. Romo
8. Stafford
9. Rivers
10. Ryan

1. Brady
2. Brees
3. Rodgers
4. P. Manning
5. Stafford
6. E. Manning
7. Rivers
8. Freeman
9. Roethlisberger
10. Ryan

Funny thing is almost everyone here would have put Rivers 1-4 in the last few years. Shows how much we know.

Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brady
Brees

I love Brady as much as the next guy but I think it's kind of hard to not have Rodgers at #1 right now.

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Eli
Rivers
Cutler
Stafford
Cam Newton
10. Romo, Vick, Flacco, or Ryan--take your pick. Roethlesberger is garbage.

rodgers number 1 right now. to take brady over rodgers is complete homerism.

1. Payton Manning (when health Easily the best non clutch QB)
2. Tom Brady (need I say more...TFB)
3. Rogers (hate the belt thing he does ...ego)
4. Brees (shut up and sign)
5. Rivers (too many bumps to the noggen)
6. Roethlisberger (too many bumps to the hoggen)
7. Vick (too many bumps to the doggen)
8. Stafford (up and coming fast
9. Eli Manning (luckiest bastage in the universe)
10. Romo (how the heck did you get here)

TommyBrady12 said:

rodgers number 1 right now. to take brady over rodgers is complete homerism.

Click to expand...

What a silly notion, given Brady's past two seasons.


Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger
Rivers
Schaub
E. Manning
Ryan
Stafford
Romo

I am not including Peyton in these rankings. If he's healthy, he's right at or near the top. But I don't think it's fair to rank him since we don't know how he'll be.

As for me being a homer putting Brady at one, call me whatever you'd like. I'd still pick him over anyone else.

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
4. E. Manning
5. Stafford
6. Roethlisberger
7. Cutler
8. Rivers
9. Ryan
10. Newton

Patstopia said:

1. Payton Manning (when healthy easily the best non clutch QB)

Click to expand...

How does being non-clutch help hold the #1 spot on any list of top quarterbacks in the league? The question was not about regular season stats or career numbers, it is about who is best right now.

1. Brady
2. Rogers
3. Brees
4. Stafford
5. Roethlisberger
6. Eli Manning
7. Newton
8. Rivers
9. Ryan
10. Cutler

incomplete based on uncertain health status, age, and a new system: Peyton Manning.

Palm Beach Pats Fan said:

How does being non-clutch help hold the #1 spot on any list of top quarterbacks in the league? The question was not about regular season stats or career numbers, it is about who is best right now.

Click to expand...

And I answered that! He is the best in the league when healthy, the same as Dan Marino was. They just arent clutch. Similar to Eli Manning unable to play consistantly during the regular season.
Thats the way I see it, how is putting Newton with one year and a 6-10 record on the top 10 less questionable?
Because it's all opinion!

Patstopia said:

And I answered that! He is the best in the league when healthy, the same as Dan Marino was. They just arent clutch. Similar to Eli Manning unable to play consistantly during the regular season.
Thats the way I see it, how is putting Newton with one year and a 6-10 record on the top 10 less questionable?
Because it's all opinion!

Click to expand...

I'm not sure what you're basing your opinion on, though. The numbers don't support your claim. History doesn't support your claim. Recent MVP voting doesn't support your claim.

etc....

Patstopia said:

And I answered that! He is the best in the league when healthy, the same as Dan Marino was.

Click to expand...

But the non-clutch qualification you have to offer would seem to demand that your contention is:

He is the best in the league when healthy, except for the many situations demanding clutch play, such as playoff games.

I cannot fathom why situations demanding clutch play would be excluded from the overall analysis.

Sure it's just opinion, and all of us are entitled to an opinion, but when the opinion and the accompanying comment are in complete opposition, you should expect that some might want you to explain why you feel lack of clutchness is insignificant with respect to evaluating QB play.

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Peyton Manning (healthy)
5. Eli Manning
6. Roethlisberger
7. Matthew Stafford
8. Philip Rivers
9. Cam Newton
10. Matt Ryan

Mossed said:

I love Brady as much as the next guy but I think it's kind of hard to not have Rodgers at #1 right now.

Click to expand...

Brady has faced higher quality defenses for the most part than Rodgers has.

Patstopia said:

1. Payton Manning (when health Easily the best non clutch QB)
2. Tom Brady (need I say more...TFB)
3. Rogers (hate the belt thing he does ...ego)
4. Brees (shut up and sign)
5. Rivers (too many bumps to the noggen)
6. Roethlisberger (too many bumps to the hoggen)
7. Vick (too many bumps to the doggen)
8. Stafford (up and coming fast
9. Eli Manning (luckiest bastage in the universe)
10. Romo (how the heck did you get here)

Click to expand...

Agree. It's actually quite lame that he does that. Great QB though, but yeah the belt thing is stupid.

Patstopia said:

1. Payton Manning (when health Easily the best non clutch QB)

Click to expand...

Brady's better than Manning in nearly every measurable statistic, not the least of which are rings, wins, winning %, playoff winning % (by a country mile), QB rating, and TD/INT ratio.

Brady ended the debate several years ago. Where have you been?