Brady & Manning against common opponents

Added one for you

theQB said:

In six out of those seven seasons...

Click to expand...

Manning had better weapons and a better OL.

theQB said:

In five out of those seven seasons, Manning had the higher completion percentage.

In five of the seven seasons, Manning passed for more yards.

In five of the seven seasons, Manning threw more touchdowns.

In four out of the seven seasons, Manning threw less interceptions.

In five out of the seven seasons, Manning fumbled less (once they were tied).

In five out of the seven seasons, Manning had the higher quarterback rating.

Click to expand...

You should link Ryan's article.

In three out of the seven seasons, Brady...?

Fixit said:

Career, guy. Career.

And outdoors vs. indoors is a better barometer, seeing as he plays at least nine games in a dome every season. Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts - Split Statistics - NFL - Yahoo! Sports

Click to expand...

What's more clearer than the present day?

When the Colts win it all this year.

Fixit said:

You should link Ryan's article.

In three out of the seven seasons, Brady...?

Click to expand...

Which one theres like 12.

It would have just leaned your bias opinion even more. Sort of like that useless crap King writes.

theQB said:

When the Colts win it all this year.

Click to expand...

That's a mighty big prediction for a team that has a history of resting it's starters to the point of rusting up and falling apart in the post season.

theQB said:

Which one theres like 12.

Click to expand...

I'm referring to the one you're currently plagiarizing: Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady: A Look Inside the Numbers | Bleacher Report

SoCalPatsfan90 said:

That's a mighty big prediction for a team that has a history of resting it's starters to the point of rusting up and falling apart in the post season.

Click to expand...

They're the hands down favorites. I'm just calling it like I see it, like you guys did all those years when you were on top.

theQB said:

Look at the statistics posted by both quarterbacks in their first seven active seasons, also when Brady's team was earning his championships....

Peyton Manning: 2,464-of-3,880 (63.5%) for 29,460 yards; 216 TD passes, 120 INT's, 213 rushing attempts for 620 rushing yards, 9 rushing TD's, 38 fumbles (13 lost).

Tom Brady: 2,293-of-3,639 (63.0%) for 26,364 yards; 197 TD passes, 86 INT's, 267 rushing attempts for 533 yards, 5 rushing TD's, 65 fumbles (29 lost).

Where do you go from here stupid?

Click to expand...

Comparing the first 7 seasons of Manning and Brady, Manning has averaged 2 more tds per season, and 442 more yds. The reason for that is Manning was surrounded by a better offensive supporting cast. In all 7 of Manning's first 7 seasons he played with a slate of a-list receivers while Brady has played only one of his first 7 seasons with a comparable receiving corps. In Manning's first 7 seasons he played with 12 offensive probowlers. In Brady's first 7 seasons he played with 7 offensive probowlers

In the Colts season before Manning, their record was 3-13 record with 310 points scored. The Colts first season with Manning 3-13 record, 310 points scored.

In the Patriots season before Brady, 5-11 record, 276 points scored. In the Patriots first season with Brady 11-3 record, 351 points scored, and a superbowl championship.

theQB said:

Who threw the game winning pass?

Click to expand...

The referees

theQB said:

They're the hands down favorites. I'm just calling it like I see it, like you guys did all those years when you were on top.

Click to expand...

oh they are the favorites for sure. So were we in '07...

Jetssuck said:

The referees

Click to expand...

No team has the refs as far in their pocket like the New England Patr*ots and good ole Krafty.

Jetssuck said:

Comparing the first 7 seasons of Manning and Brady, Manning has averaged 2 more tds per season, and 442 more yds. The reason for that is Manning was surrounded by a better offensive supporting cast. In all 7 of Manning's first 7 seasons he played with a slate of a-list receivers while Brady has played only one of his first 7 seasons with a comparable receiving corps. In Manning's first 7 seasons he played with 12 offensive probowlers. In Brady's first 7 seasons he played with 7 offensive probowlers

In the Colts season before Manning, their record was 3-13 record with 310 points scored. The Colts first season with Manning 3-13 record, 310 points scored.

In the Patriots season before Brady, 5-11 record, 276 points scored. In the Patriots first season with Brady 11-3 record, 351 points scored, and a superbowl championship.

Click to expand...

2008 with out Brady, 11-5 Lolz

theQB said:

2008 with out Brady, 11-5 Lolz

Click to expand...

That's actually a pretty good point. After all, they were an inexcusable dropped Gaffney TD away from beating the Colts in Indy.

Brady sucks.

Peyton Manning record in postseason: 6-8. How can you call someone the GOAT if they have a LOSING record in the post season?

Why are we even arguing, these are 2 sure-fire first ballot Hall Of Famers. Let's just sit back and enjoy their careers. These numbers being put up in the original poster's thread opener are quite intersting IMO. The Colts definitely play in a pass happy stadium, and a pass happy division (weaker pass defenses than the AFC EAST), so when the numbers are put in perspective, it makes things look more interesting. BUT, I have to hand it to Manning, he's played on a team that has suffered some big injuries to the secondary, and a lack of a running game, and still has his team at 14-1 (Reminds me of the 2003 & 2004 Pats, lotsa injuries).

Brady has had a remarkable season, considering he missed a whole season. Statistically, he's had his second best season ever, despite, not having a good running game, despite, being rusty from missing a whole season, despite, not having a world class Tight End, and despite really only having 2 receivers. And let's not forget, the Pats had one of the 5 toughest schedules in football.

2 Great QB's, the best of this era (and decade). Like the old Marino vs Montana arguments, these arguments can go on forever. I'll take our guy (Brady), cause he seems more clutch in big games.

Fixit said:

I'm referring to the one you're currently plagiarizing: Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady: A Look Inside the Numbers | Bleacher Report

Click to expand...

This article would have been a lot more interesting from the approach of the OP. "Manning vs. Brady: A Look Inside the Numbers Against Common Opponents". A mouthful of a headline but maybe a clearer picture...

Peyton's numbers could possibly be skewed by the fact that since '02 he has for the most part had weaker divisional competition...

theQB said:

No team has the refs in their pocket.

Click to expand...

Actually you could have just said that and not sounded ******ed... Both teams have gotten calls, as have the Giants and others etc... Might want to stop posting crap like this...

theQB said:

2008 with out Brady, 11-5 Lolz

Click to expand...

2008 Colts without Manning 1-0. Higher winning % than Patriots without Brady.

Cassel's passer rating with the Patriots was 88.2, Jim Sorgi's rating with the Colts 89.9

SoCalPatsfan90 said:

Actually you could have just said that and not sounded ******ed... Both teams have gotten calls, as have the Giants and others etc... Might want to stop posting crap like this...

Click to expand...

Are you kidding, Brady cries at the refs more than any player this decade.

theQB said:

Are you kidding, Brady cries at the refs more than any player this decade.

Click to expand...

Oh, so you are a Colts fan. That was some disguise!