This is how I see it.
I think he needs to compete like everybody else, and I think he can win (read: earn) a spot next year. I think he is able to contribute. I trust him to field a big punt in a big game, regardless of what happened last year.
Troy has always been my favorite Patriot and if he retires I think it will be because he can not contribute as a player on the field.
If he retires as a patriot player, I would like to see him in the organization, possibly as a receivers coach.
Ultimately, I want him to do what is right for him. If he wants to take time off and get away from football for a bit then cool...
Either way Troy gave us some awesome memories...that we know....