Bill Cowher's Top 18 Quarterbacks

[PonyExpress]

You're insane.

Go F yourself.

 

[Sivy]

Bret farve is better that payton manning

 

[primetime]

Bret farve is better that payton manning

He certainly has played better than him for most of this year. For the career though? Have to give the edge to Manning... you could say it's close, but I don't think it will be when their respective careers are done.

Go F yourself.

Pleasant. Were you expecting a different reaction after making a claim like that? Roethlisnuts better than Manning?

 

[Patriot_in_NY]

Favre is better than Roethlisberger.

Agreed........

I'd also put Anderson in the top 10, over McNabb for sure. He's the Best Anderson to play in Ohio since Kenny

 

[Lansdowne]

Manning playing most of his career in the frozen tundra? BAHAHAHAHAHA... I'd say right now I would rather have Manning than Favre, but career-wise, advantage Favre.

 

[Sivy]

He certainly has played better than him for most of this year. For the career though? Have to give the edge to Manning... you could say it's close, but I don't think it will be when their respective careers are done.


Only because manning is showing his true colors, that Id say brett is better than he is. Its obvios that manning is basically an average qb without his pro wide outs. Farve has what? 3 mvps? and a superbowl ring, yea manning has great numbers, but this season is showing what he's trully made off. I could see the pack going 15-1, and the colts losing 3 more games.

 

[A.C Vegas]

If Anderson keeps up this pace there is going to be a QB controversy next year in Cleveland and who ever wins they are going to have some nice trade bait. question just for you Aqua would you be mad if Anderson one out and then Miami traded for Quinn? I think i would be mad.

 

[RayClay]

Personally I put Rothlesberger at #2, ahead of Manning. Rothlesberger is the most physically talented Qb since Elway, and he is the reason Pittsburgh has been so good the last few years. IMO he is the greatest threat to the Pats' this season and in seasons to come. Discounting last season, when his face was smashed by a windshield, he has had the greatest start to a QB career in NFL history.

9 21 42.9 123 5.9 0 2 1 8 22.6

 

[VJCPatriot]

Anderson should be in the top 10 and Eli Manning does not belong in any top 10 list yet. It gets pretty sketchy either way after say the top 8 QBs though.

 

[RodThePat]

What do you know. He puts his ex-QB third. Problem with Big Ben is he doesn't/can't win games on his own with his arm if thier run game gets stopped. I'd put Farve and even Romo above Ben.

Isn't that what Ben did last week?

 

[hallfamebrady]

Agreed........

I'd also put Anderson in the top 10, over McNabb for sure. He's the Best Anderson to play in Ohio since Kenny

If Anderson is in the top 10, what does that mean for Brady Quinn?

 

[IcyPatriot]

I think that list pissed off Jason Campbell ... he's having a great day against the Cowboys. Also, Eli Manning does not even belong on the list ... he's playing like a journeyman QB ... because that's what he should be.