JMC00
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2012
- Messages
- 16,735
- Reaction score
- 25,369
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Would it affect league policy to give Peyton some defensive pass interference or would those just be ruled inconclusive automatically. :bricks:Well, it'd be 30 yards a game more for the opposition to overcome just from holding FINALLY being called on the LT for mauling Chandler Jones!
It should cut out on some of the other BS you see in every game every week.
I don't entirely agree with Belichick here. Challenging a holding call or pass interference is asking for a 2nd opinion. I don't like that idea.
However, challenging something like fair-catch interference where it's black and white whether you contacted the punt returner. I think you should be able to challenge that.
I agree. I feel like part of the cat and mouse game between corners and wide receivers is the grey line between legal and holding/illegal contact. Every good corner TECHNICALLY breaks the rules by giving a tiny tug with every contact. They'll get away with it for 99% of the game, but then a coach can come along on a pivotal play at the end, knowing he can technically win a challenge to extend a drive.
Leave judgment calls out of it, unless you can find a way to make them more black and white.
I am in complete, 100% agreement. Everything - E V E R Y T H I N G - should be challengeable.
You say that because the Panthers game is so fresh in everybody’s head but when the games start lasting from 1pm to 630pm with 50% of that time with a ref under the hood you’d have a different outlook. Human error is part of sports, you make everything challengeable and before long you’re playing a video game.
did you read the article? Coaches would still only have 2 (3 if the prior 2 are successful) challenges per game. they can't challenge every play, that would (indeed) be ridiculous.You say that because the Panthers game is so fresh in everybody’s head but when the games start lasting from 1pm to 630pm with 50% of that time with a ref under the hood you’d have a different outlook. Human error is part of sports, you make everything challengeable and before long you’re playing a video game.