UK_Pat37
Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job
- Joined
- Dec 17, 2011
- Messages
- 1,452
- Reaction score
- 172
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Carson Palmer is no genius, and for most of his career Chad was a better receiver than Palmer was a QB imo. He had a pretty elite receiving corps and was still pretty mediocre.
let him be himself and he will be the seconds best WR on the team
It's funny I still remember him and Carson on the sidelines, arguing after a missed pass, Ocho slicing his hand thru the air to show the route he thought he was to run, Carson patiently shaking his head "no". Now I understand what Carson must have been dealing with.
That said I hope he finally gets it. But as some posters have said, it's usually lights on or lights off. Straight away. I wish I knew more about the plays and expected adjustments to understand why he can't figure it out. BB must also put a premium on the weakest link philosophy. Figuring if you don't understand the play, you're just hurting the team. Which I guess makes sense as that's one of the Pats greatest strength -the little team things- WR blocking or slight route picks/rubs for example.
On a related side note, I did gain more respect for Carson for never throwing 85 under the bus in those situations; I still distinctly remember a weird strained look on his face during a mid-game taped segment on the dynamic pair back then while 85 joked he could do no wrong and they were superman and aquaman or something stupid like that... To me that's the team leadership a QB must possess. Knowing your teammates. Willing to take a public hit to keep the team in harmony. But it must of been hard to bite his tounge all season without a peep. Of course this is all my conjecture and armchair psycho-analysis, but thanks for listening.
TyronePoole said:Carson Palmer is no genius, and for most of his career Chad was a better receiver than Palmer was a QB imo. He had a pretty elite receiving corps and was still pretty mediocre.
If McD goes back to the vertical style offence we saw in 2007, I can see Chad making the team. It suis him much better.
I actually feel bad for Chad and wanted him to do well with the Pats. A big part of that was knowing how elated he was to arrive in NE. You just knew it was something he really wanted. He just couldn't cut it.
I think he'll do fine elsewhere when he's gotta learn 30 or so specific plays and not need to mathematically discern multiple variations on even more after the snap.
I think Nun has the best handle on this and bears repeating. If your name ISN'T Welker or Lloyd, you'd better be prepared to literally fight for your professional life in TC.....and of course that too includes Ocho. A couple of other points.
1. The Pats are missing picks in the 5th and 6th rounds next season, I wouldn't be surprised to see one or more of Ocho, Stalworth, Gonsales or Gaffney, traded to a team who decides they need a competent veteran WR in mid August, due to injuries or lack of talent.
2. I find that remarks like "Chad sucks" offensive. The guy has been a consistent try hard, productive WR for a decade, and has accumulated over 11,000 receiving yds on some very bad teams. Its OK to criticize him for not "getting" the playbook early on. Its OK to speculate that his skills have eroded. But its NOT OK to simply discard the bulk of a VERY good career with a snide dismissive remarks. He might be a clown off the field, but never on it, and deserves a certain amount of respect for what he's accomplished - JMHO
So you want to let him run the wrong routes, and that will help the team?
C'mon T, you should know the answer to that. If they wait those "couple of weeks" there is no sure way they will get the player they need, because they all those final cuts go to the waiver wire, not to FA. Plus, if you decide you need a vet WR, you'd want him to be in your system at least a couple of weeks before the season startsWhy wouldnt a team just wait a couple of weeks for roster cutdowns and pay nothing?
Ocho wouldnt be worth much. His struggles are well chronicled. Gaffney has improved 3 seasons in succession.
I'm sure YOU know better, but if BB decides to keep Ocho over Gaffney it will be because HE felt Ocho won the job.If the Pats get rid of Gaffney and keep Ocho, BB has lost his mind.
No, with more conference he will think clearer
Why wouldnt a team just wait a couple of weeks for roster cutdowns and pay nothing?
Ocho wouldnt be worth much. His struggles are well chronicled. Gaffney has improved 3 seasons in succession. If the Pats get rid of Gaffney and keep Ocho, BB has lost his mind.
Thats assuming a lot. I have never seen 85 to be a guy who lacked confidence.
Your comment suggested we redirect the offense to what 85 wants to do. Why would we do that when we have at least 4 better receivers who all are capable of doing what the offense asks of them?
If 85 was our 2nd best reciever, why was he so pathetic last year? What is he going to learn in his second year that he couldn't figure out in a full season?
I think Chad acting a fool makes him more comfortable and will allow him to learn the offense better and more clearly. I said he could be the second best, I did not say he currently was