PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Trading Up (DL Melvin Ingram or Michael Brockers)


Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh?
spock.gif


.........



It was edited because the quotes code were messed up. LOL way to jump to conclusions buddy.
 
If Jonathan Martin, offensive tackle from Stanford, falls to the #27 overall pick, I would not doubt that Bill Belichick gets a call from Andy Reid. Please consider the fact the Philadelphia Eagles own two second round draft selections, so trading up may be an option. The Philadelphia Eagles could be searching for a long term solution at left tackle due to the Achilles' tendon injury to Jason Peters.

They signed Demetress Bell of the Bills to a five year contract.
 
Please don't let us trade up too far for Brockers, same would go for Coples if he had been mentioned . Ingram I would take but I'd rather have 2 first rounders (if they were going to be used) than using both for Melvin.
 
Way to try to BS your way out'f getting BUSTED, buddy!! ;)



Classic!!
jester.gif

Nice detective work there Matlock.

Too bad I really didn't edit anything to do with what you quoted. I edited because the code to quote something was off.

Nice try. I'll give you a B for effort but an F for execution. Maybe next time you'll have something of substance to post.
 
He's in the business of putting together the best team he can, and trading down into the 2nd round has NOT worked out.

Passing on Clay Mathews to accumulate picks and take 2nd rounders like Ron Brace and Darius freaking Butler did NOT make us a better team.


From 2006-2010 we have had 15 picks in the 2nd and 3rd rounds. Out of those 15 picks only 4 have turned out good. 11 have been BUSTS on our team. I am not counting last year since it's too early to tell still.




Like I said, he obviously wouldn't have had a projected Top 15 player like Melvin Ingram visiting Gilette if he wasn't considering trading up.

Even Brockers would most likely require trading up about 5-10 spots to pick.



BB wouldn't waste time and resources having these guys visit Gilette if he had no interest in trading up.


Mr. Drake, I like your thread, and I am all for trading up for Brockers, whose game film shows that he is a true competitor who whips the opposing O-Line in the 2nd half when he has figured out how they play him. I am impressed with Ingram too even if he has T-Rex arms.

But for goodness sake, Clay Matthews is not good. He is a one-trick pony who lost his one trick last year; I have a strong suspicion he juiced his way to that one trick anyway. He would NOT fit in with a Belichick defense that demands accountability to your assignment, rather than simply running around wherever you damn well please until you hit the quarterback. He is football's most overrated player. Plus, while Butler/Brace certainly didn't work out, I think it has been proven MULTIPLE TIMES on this very forum that the trade gave the Pats the ammo they needed to secure Rob Gronkowski, who will (barring injury) go down as one of the greatest tight ends to ever play the game. He is already the best tight end I've ever seen. Just for that alone, can we get off the Matthews BS? He's not very good, the Pats got Gronk out of the trade...let's move on. Goodness.
 
RUN, Forrest, RUN!!
jester.gif

Dude... honestly... You seem to be missing a few brain cells. Perhaps you should stick to your horrific scouting reports where every player has fantastically magnificent super duper talent!!!

LOL. All jokes aside, what are you blabbing on about? I didn't edit the part that I was accused of, I edited the quote code. It happens. You're not proving anything. All you're doing is spamming and boosting your post count. Now go away little boy.
 
Mr. Drake, I like your thread, and I am all for trading up for Brockers, whose game film shows that he is a true competitor who whips the opposing O-Line in the 2nd half when he has figured out how they play him. I am impressed with Ingram too even if he has T-Rex arms.

But for goodness sake, Clay Matthews is not good. He is a one-trick pony who lost his one trick last year; I have a strong suspicion he juiced his way to that one trick anyway. He would NOT fit in with a Belichick defense that demands accountability to your assignment, rather than simply running around wherever you damn well please until you hit the quarterback. He is football's most overrated player. Plus, while Butler/Brace certainly didn't work out, I think it has been proven MULTIPLE TIMES on this very forum that the trade gave the Pats the ammo they needed to secure Rob Gronkowski, who will (barring injury) go down as one of the greatest tight ends to ever play the game. He is already the best tight end I've ever seen. Just for that alone, can we get off the Matthews BS? He's not very good, the Pats got Gronk out of the trade...let's move on. Goodness.

Thanks for the compliment.

I don't see how Matthews is a 1 trick pony though. While his sack numbers went down, his numbers show he's a much more rounded and complete player now. He had career highs in Interceptions and Forced Fumbles last year. And while he didn't put up as many sacks as he did in his first 2 years, he had almost the same amount of QB pressures as he did in their SuperBowl year when he gained popularity. While he may be overrated a tad bit, he's done a HELL OF A LOT MORE than Darius Butler and Ron Brace combined.

My point in showing BB's 2nd nd 3rd round failure rates was to show that we SHOULD trade up because there's a high chance the picks used to trade up would end up as busts anyways.

As far as not getting Gronk goes... We still could've got Gronk in 2010 as we had another 2nd round pick 11 spots later that we used on Jermaine Cunningham.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the compliment.

I don't see how Matthews is a 1 trick pony though. While his sack numbers went down, his numbers show he's a much more rounded and complete player now. He had career highs in Interceptions and Forced Fumbles last year. And while he didn't put up as many sacks as he did in his first 2 years, he had almost the same amount of QB pressures as he did in their SuperBowl year when he gained popularity. While he may be overrated a tad bit, he's done a HELL OF A LOT MORE than Darius Butler and Ron Brace combined.

My point in showing BB's 2nd nd 3rd round failure rates was to show that we SHOULD trade up because there's a high chance the picks used to trade up would end up as busts anyways.

As far as not getting Gronk goes... We still could've got Gronk in 2010 as we had another 2nd round pick 11 spots later that we used on Jermaine Cunningham.

This is a fair point, I just think it's getting tiresome to talk about a player that plays an undisciplined style of football that does not fit in with what the Patriots do on defense. For the Pats, Matthews would be a 1 down player.

He makes a lot of splash plays, and I know that's exciting, but the Packers' defense was brutal last season, with a guy who is alleged to be one of the most dominant defenders in the league leading the way. Two of those interceptions were thrown right into his gut, I remember seeing them. He is a net negative against the run.

Was I a bit harsh in calling him bad? Maybe. But I fail to see how he's any better than Cameron Wake, a guy the Patriots could have simply signed, rather than use a first round pick on him, and people don't have an obsession with how we missed out on him. He and Connor Barwin stick in my craw significantly more than Clay III.

His dad, his hair, his team...it's a perfect storm for the media to obsess over a player who is a knockoff version of his position coach, Kevin Greene.

But I do not mean to hijack this thread...I'm extremely excited about the interest they are showing in Brockers. He's young and raw, but I think he'd be a really nice addition to the defense, even if it takes him a year to figure things out. He puts a lot of that up the gut pressure that Seymour used to, he gets his mitts on a lot of passes, he's a beast against the run, and he was doing all of this as a young player in the toughest conference in college football. Just on film, he strikes me as a competitor who gets better as the game goes on. He uses his hands the entire game; he isn't a leaner. He was absolutely whipping the Georgia and Bama OLs in the 2nd half of their games; there are a lot of NFL caliber players on those lines.

Ingram may be a guy that Belichick breaks his "rules" for, or he could just be doing his due diligence to see if he wants to change up his physical requirements. I'm more convinced the Pats' interest in Brockers is legit, but Ingram made a ton of plays last year at South Carolina and is a unique athlete (witness his touchdown on the fake punt).
 
That's OK, Drake, old cat: I'm laughed out. :D

Carry on with your bad self. ;)
 
I want to start off by saying im not a huge fan of brockers or ingram now if you could put the skills of ingram into brockers body that would be one hell of a player, but i do understand the importance of impact players on defense. Which got me doing some research and i found that 49 players have been named to the AP All-Pro team in the last 6 years from the defensive line and linebacker positions. 68% have been from the first round of the draft and 57% have been from the top 15 picks in the draft. Excluding Repeat players 62.5% have been from the first round and 50% have been from the top 15 picks. This proves that it is very difficult to find an impact defensive front 7 player unless you are in the top half of the first round draft. Compared to the offensive which has 36 players have been named to the AP All-Pro team in the last 6 years from the QB,RB,WR, and TE positions. 53% have been from the first round of the draft and 31% have been from the top 15 picks in the draft. Excluding Repeat players 52% have been from the first round and 24% have been from the top 15 picks. After seeing this pattern I would be inclined to trade-up into the first half of the draft for the right player.

2011
Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Haloti Ngata Rd 1 Pick 12
Jason P-Paul Rd 1 Pick 15
Justin Smith Rd 1 Pick 4
Terrell Suggs Rd 1 Pick 10
DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Derrick Johnson Rd 1 Pick 15
NaVorro Bowman Rd 3 Pick 91

2010
Julius Peppers Rd 1 Pick 2
John Abraham Rd 1 Pick 13
*Haloti Ngata Rd 1 Pick 12
N Suh Rd 1 Pick 2
Clay Matthews Rd 1 Pick 26
James Harrison UNDRAFTED
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Jerod Mayo Rd 1 Pick 10

2009
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Dwight Freeny Rd 1 Pick 11
Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Jay Ratliff Rd 7 Pick 224
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Elvis Dumervil Rd 4 Pick 126
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Ray Lewis Rd 1 Pick 26

2008
Justin Tuck Rd 3 Pick 74
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Albert Hworth Rd 1 Pick 15
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
*James Harrison UNDRAFTED
*Ray Lewis Rd 1 Pick 26
Jon Beason Rd 1 Pick 25

2007
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Patrick Kerney Rd 1 Pick 30
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
*Albert Hworth Rd 1 Pick 15
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Mike Vrabel Rd 3 Pick 91
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Lofa Tatupu Rd 2 Pick 45

2006
Jason Taylor Rd 3 Pick 73
*Julius Peppers Rd 1 Pick 2
Jamal Williams SD
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Brian Urlacher Rd 1 Pick 9
Zach Thomas Rd 5 Pick 154
Adalius Thomas Rd 6 Pick 186
Shawn Merriman Rd 1 Pick 12

* Previous All-Pro

Total (excluding duplicates)
Rd 1 Top 16
Rd 1 Bottom 4
Rd 2 1
Rd 3 4
Rd 4 2
Rd 5 1
Rd 6 1
RD 7 1
SD 1
UD 1

Players with multiple selections
Rd 1 Top 12
Rd 1 Bottom 1
RD 4 3
UD 1

2011
Aaron Rodgers Rd 1 Pick 24
Maurice JonesDrew Rd 2 Pick 60
LeSean McCoy Rd 2 Pick 53
Rob Gronkowski Rd 2 Pick 42
Calvin Johnson Rd 1 Pick 2
Wes Welker UNDRAFTED

2010
Tom Brady Rd 6 Pick 199
Arian Foster UNDRAFTED
Jamaal Charles Rd 3 Pick 73
Roddy White Rd 1 Pick 27
Reggie Wayne Rd 1 Pick 30
Jason Witten Rd 3 Pick 69

2009
Peyton Manning Rd 1 Pick 1
Chris Johnson Rd 1 Pick 24
Adrian Peterson Rd 1 Pick 7
Andre Johnson Rd 1 Pick 3
*Wes Welker UNDRAFTED
Dallas Clark Rd 1 Pick 24

2008
*Peyton Manning Rd 1 Pick 1
*Adrian Peterson Rd 1 Pick 7
Micheal Turner Rd 5 Pick 154
*Andre Johnson Rd 1 Pick 3
Larry Fitzgerald Rd 1 Pick 3
Tony Gonzalez Rd 1 Pick 13

2007
*Tom Brady Rd 6 Pick 199
L Tomlinson Rd 1 Pick 5
Brian Westbrook Rd 3 Pick 91
Randy Moss Rd 1 Pick 21
Terrell Owen Rd 3 Pick 89
*Jason Witten Rd 3 Pick 69

2006
Drew Brees Rd 2 Pick 32
*L Tomlinson Rd 1 Pick 5
Larry Johnson Rd 1 Pick 27
Marvin Harrison Rd 1 Pick 19
Chad Johnson Rd 2 Pick 36
Antonio Gates UNDRAFTED

* Previous All-Pro

Total (excluding players with multiple selections)
Rd 1 Top 7
Rd 1 Bottom 8
Rd 2 5
Rd 3 4
Rd 4 0
Rd 5 1
Rd 6 1
Rd 7 0
UD 3

Players with multiple selections
Rd 1 Top 4
Rd 3 1
Rd 6 1
UD 1
 
This is a fair point, I just think it's getting tiresome to talk about a player that plays an undisciplined style of football that does not fit in with what the Patriots do on defense. For the Pats, Matthews would be a 1 down player.
If ninkovich can play as many snaps as he does, clay would play just as many here.

heck, he could probably even start at safety for us lol
 
If ninkovich can play as many snaps as he does, clay would play just as many here.

heck, he could probably even start at safety for us lol

Hey no fair hahaha, his dad would start at safety for the Pats right now! Heck, his uncle Bruce was versatile on the OL---I bet he'd get it done in the secondary! :D
 
I want to start off by saying im not a huge fan of brockers or ingram now if you could put the skills of ingram into brockers body that would be one hell of a player, but i do understand the importance of impact players on defense. Which got me doing some research and i found that 49 players have been named to the AP All-Pro team in the last 6 years from the defensive line and linebacker positions. 68% have been from the first round of the draft and 57% have been from the top 15 picks in the draft. Excluding Repeat players 62.5% have been from the first round and 50% have been from the top 15 picks. This proves that it is very difficult to find an impact defensive front 7 player unless you are in the top half of the first round draft. Compared to the offensive which has 36 players have been named to the AP All-Pro team in the last 6 years from the QB,RB,WR, and TE positions. 53% have been from the first round of the draft and 31% have been from the top 15 picks in the draft. Excluding Repeat players 52% have been from the first round and 24% have been from the top 15 picks. After seeing this pattern I would be inclined to trade-up into the first half of the draft for the right player.

2011
Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Haloti Ngata Rd 1 Pick 12
Jason P-Paul Rd 1 Pick 15
Justin Smith Rd 1 Pick 4
Terrell Suggs Rd 1 Pick 10
DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Derrick Johnson Rd 1 Pick 15
NaVorro Bowman Rd 3 Pick 91

2010
Julius Peppers Rd 1 Pick 2
John Abraham Rd 1 Pick 13
*Haloti Ngata Rd 1 Pick 12
N Suh Rd 1 Pick 2
Clay Matthews Rd 1 Pick 26
James Harrison UNDRAFTED
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Jerod Mayo Rd 1 Pick 10

2009
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Dwight Freeny Rd 1 Pick 11
Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Jay Ratliff Rd 7 Pick 224
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Elvis Dumervil Rd 4 Pick 126
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Ray Lewis Rd 1 Pick 26

2008
Justin Tuck Rd 3 Pick 74
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Albert Hworth Rd 1 Pick 15
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
*James Harrison UNDRAFTED
*Ray Lewis Rd 1 Pick 26
Jon Beason Rd 1 Pick 25

2007
*Jared Allen Rd 4 Pick 126
Patrick Kerney Rd 1 Pick 30
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
*Albert Hworth Rd 1 Pick 15
*DeMarcus Ware Rd 1 Pick 11
Mike Vrabel Rd 3 Pick 91
*Patrick Willis Rd 1 Pick 11
Lofa Tatupu Rd 2 Pick 45

2006
Jason Taylor Rd 3 Pick 73
*Julius Peppers Rd 1 Pick 2
Jamal Williams SD
*Kevin Williams Rd 1 Pick 9
Brian Urlacher Rd 1 Pick 9
Zach Thomas Rd 5 Pick 154
Adalius Thomas Rd 6 Pick 186
Shawn Merriman Rd 1 Pick 12

* Previous All-Pro

Total (excluding duplicates)
Rd 1 Top 16
Rd 1 Bottom 4
Rd 2 1
Rd 3 4
Rd 4 2
Rd 5 1
Rd 6 1
RD 7 1
SD 1
UD 1

Players with multiple selections
Rd 1 Top 12
Rd 1 Bottom 1
RD 4 3
UD 1

2011
Aaron Rodgers Rd 1 Pick 24
Maurice JonesDrew Rd 2 Pick 60
LeSean McCoy Rd 2 Pick 53
Rob Gronkowski Rd 2 Pick 42
Calvin Johnson Rd 1 Pick 2
Wes Welker UNDRAFTED

2010
Tom Brady Rd 6 Pick 199
Arian Foster UNDRAFTED
Jamaal Charles Rd 3 Pick 73
Roddy White Rd 1 Pick 27
Reggie Wayne Rd 1 Pick 30
Jason Witten Rd 3 Pick 69

2009
Peyton Manning Rd 1 Pick 1
Chris Johnson Rd 1 Pick 24
Adrian Peterson Rd 1 Pick 7
Andre Johnson Rd 1 Pick 3
*Wes Welker UNDRAFTED
Dallas Clark Rd 1 Pick 24

2008
*Peyton Manning Rd 1 Pick 1
*Adrian Peterson Rd 1 Pick 7
Micheal Turner Rd 5 Pick 154
*Andre Johnson Rd 1 Pick 3
Larry Fitzgerald Rd 1 Pick 3
Tony Gonzalez Rd 1 Pick 13

2007
*Tom Brady Rd 6 Pick 199
L Tomlinson Rd 1 Pick 5
Brian Westbrook Rd 3 Pick 91
Randy Moss Rd 1 Pick 21
Terrell Owen Rd 3 Pick 89
*Jason Witten Rd 3 Pick 69

2006
Drew Brees Rd 2 Pick 32
*L Tomlinson Rd 1 Pick 5
Larry Johnson Rd 1 Pick 27
Marvin Harrison Rd 1 Pick 19
Chad Johnson Rd 2 Pick 36
Antonio Gates UNDRAFTED

* Previous All-Pro

Total (excluding players with multiple selections)
Rd 1 Top 7
Rd 1 Bottom 8
Rd 2 5
Rd 3 4
Rd 4 0
Rd 5 1
Rd 6 1
Rd 7 0
UD 3

Players with multiple selections
Rd 1 Top 4
Rd 3 1
Rd 6 1
UD 1

How many of those players were on a team that won a Superbowl? How is it that a team could win it all with so few Pro-bowlers?

Hint: It's not about getting pro-bowl players, it's about forging pro-bowl caliber teams.

I actually don't want any guys on my team to go to the Pro-bowl, that just means they'll want more money, I want the team to win games.
 
How many of those players were on a team that won a Superbowl? How is it that a team could win it all with so few Pro-bowlers?

Hint: It's not about getting pro-bowl players, it's about forging pro-bowl caliber teams.

I actually don't want any guys on my team to go to the Pro-bowl, that just means they'll want more money, I want the team to win games.

so your telling me that if could go back in time and had the opportunity to select demarcus ware or jared allen that you wouldn't just because they are going to be pro bowlers and cost a lot of money????....TALENT wins games
 
I've always laughed off all the talk of the Pats trading up. The rumor has been around for a few weeks.

Just for fun, in a prior thread that posted the question "who would you target", Ingram was my pick for the guy most desirable in the top-10. The guy is so versatile... BB loves that more than anything. True football players. I've posted my opinion on Ingram before, wont do it again here. To me, the question isn't whether BB would want Ingram on the team, but at what cost.

The idea that BB would trade both first rounders for Ingram doesn't fit. BB works too hard to accumulate 1sts to throw them around. There was a lot of press coverage of an conversation between BB and Tim Dimitroff after Atlanta traded all those picks for Julio Jones. BB felt it was too much to give up for one guy. Belichick advised against Julio Jones trade - NFC South Blog - ESPN. So, no chance that he would do something like that himself.

But, I also have to concede that Ingram was not invited to Foxboro under the misconception that Ingram is going to somehow drop into the 20s. Impossible. And further, BB would not waste his time meeting a guy he has absolutely no shot at.

So, I'm starting to come around to the idea that maybe a trade-up is possible. It would have to be on terms that BB already feels comfortable with. What if there is a team looking to trade down, and has asked for trade value that BB already knows he is willing to give up.

What about this as a theory. The Pats were dangling Hoyer as an RFA for a 2nd, and KC was an interested party. That conversation could easily have drifted into discussion around whether the Pats would be interested in the #11 pick.

Suppose BBs friend Pioli was willing to give up #11 for a first, a second and some players? Let's call it #27, #63, Brian Hoyer and Ryan Wendell. Two backups for us that can be starters for the Chiefs. KC gets credible depth on the interior line that they need. They get QB depth that they need. The #27 could be Nick Perry and #63 could be Bobby Wagner. That's four good players that can contribute for the Chiefs on both sides of the ball.

The thing that makes it work, the deal is pretty damn affordable for the Pats. Hoyer is going to walk next year anyway, and we have Mallett on the roster already. Wendell has started for us before, and we have options along the interior line, including bringing Koppen back for his sunset years. And, best of all, it doesn't cost us both first rounders.

I could probably paint a similar scenario around the Dolphins at #8. Cleveland at #4 is not viable, but Cleveland might trade down from #22 for considerations which include Hoyer. (Maybe that's where the Brockers rumors are coming from)
 
What about this as a theory. The Pats were dangling Hoyer as an RFA for a 2nd, and KC was an interested party. That conversation could easily have drifted into discussion around whether the Pats would be interested in the #11 pick.

Suppose BBs friend Pioli was willing to give up #11 for a first, a second and some players? Let's call it #27, #63, Brian Hoyer and Ryan Wendell. Two backups for us that can be starters for the Chiefs. KC gets credible depth on the interior line that they need. They get QB depth that they need. The #27 could be Nick Perry and #63 could be Bobby Wagner. That's four good players that can contribute for the Chiefs on both sides of the ball.

The thing that makes it work, the deal is pretty damn affordable for the Pats. Hoyer is going to walk next year anyway, and we have Mallett on the roster already. Wendell has started for us before, and we have options along the interior line, including bringing Koppen back for his sunset years. And, best of all, it doesn't cost us both first rounders.

I could probably paint a similar scenario around the Dolphins at #8. Cleveland at #4 is not viable, but Cleveland might trade down from #22 for considerations which include Hoyer. (Maybe that's where the Brockers rumors are coming from)
Sorry but I personally feel that Ricky Stanzi is a better long term prospect than Brian Hoyer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/24: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
MORSE: Patriots Draft Needs and Draft Related Info
Back
Top