Is this Belichick's finest coaching job in New England to date?

[Kontradiction]

Personally, I'd say yes. The offense is missing only a flanker who is an actual deep threat, but is otherwise among the best in the league. The defense, however, has been another story throughout this season. Aside from Wilfork, Mayo, Spikes, and Chung, this has been an otherwise patchwork defense throughout the season. Yet they have made steady improvements in the playoffs and, arguably, won the AFCCG for us when Brady had an off day. No matter what your opinions on the defense have been (and most of you know mine), you can't deny that they have played steadily better in the two games we've had throughout the playoffs than they did in, say, November and December. In the regular season, the team allowed 411.1 YPG and 21.4 PPG. In the playoffs (granted, a smaller sample size, but you can feel free to take any two games in a row throughout the season and compare), they've allowed 322.5 YPG and 15 PPG. That's a difference of 88.6 YPG that correlates to the difference of 6.6 PPG.

On top of that, this is a new and younger team that only has 11 guys with Super Bowl experience on it. For the most part, a lot of these guys have been inexperienced with the stage of the playoffs (which is also a reason for blame when it comes to the Jets loss last year). Belichick and his staff have coached this guys up to be AFC champions with a very realistic shot of winning the Super Bowl if our interior O-Line can protect Brady. For my money, this has to be Belichick's best coaching job yet with the 2001 and 2008 seasons not far behind. Hopefully this year has the same end result as the '01 campaign did.

P.S. - Keep in mind I'm talking about Belichick as a COACH, not a personnel evaluator. Please keep your opinions about that aspect of his job out of this thread. And please specify why you do or don't think so after your vote. This, IMO, is an interesting debate.

 

[coolguy]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

 

[Patsfan1102]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

You're kidding right.... its impossible for it to be one of his worsts considering the PATS are in the superbowl

 

[Kontradiction]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

You're saying that as a personnel evaluator. As a coach, it's remarkable that he coached his team into the Super Bowl even WITH the defense.

 

[wizwor]

Talk to me Monday. I think 2001-2 was his best coaching job -- he got max performance out of every player on that team.

This year feels a lot like that. If they win Sunday, you might be able to compare the two, but 2001-2 was surreal.

 

[coolguy]

You're saying that as a personnel evaluator. As a coach, it's remarkable that he coached his team into the Super Bowl even WITH the defense.

I think his success is more to do with brady than his coaching.

You can't argue that bill made Tom's job much harder than it's ever been. It's basically brady or bust and hope the clock runs out before the other team can score.

 

[MP-Logick]

There's a lot more talent overall on this team then the 2001 team. I still have no idea how we won the Super Bowl that year.

 

[DarrylS]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

Wish there was an unlike button, but instead will keep it brief. This team does not have the best defense, but it knows how to win as a team.

Not sure if it is BB's best performance, but very close to the top. Not sure that anything can match what happened in '01.

 

[coolguy]

Wish there was an unlike button, but instead will keep it brief. This team does not have the best defense, but it knows how to win as a team.

Not sure if it is BB's best performance, but very close to the top. Not sure that anything can match what happened in '01.

You can't say that though. Brady feels pressure to put up points unlike any season he's ever had.

I'll put it like this
In 2007 The patriots put up 30 points because they could
In 2011 the patriots put up 30 points because they had to

 

[supafly]

You know, Kontra I have been wondering that same question lately.

With the remarkable job that he's done all year with the following issues, I think it's a great question. I do think that we have to win on Sunday though, for us to be able to say that it was his greatest job ever.

Consider the following:

---labor dispute

---probably the best job ever at free agency

(Waters)

(Light)

(Mankins)

(Carter)

(Anderson)

(G.Warren)

(Ellis)

(Ihedigbo)

with misses of Ochocinco and Haynesworth

---The draft, and continuing to set up the team's future

(Solder)

(Mallett)

(Ridley)

(Vereen)

(S.Moore)

(Dowling)

AND future 1st and 2nd rounders for this 2012 draft...all impressive

---the managing of the injury situation

Losing the starting Center, the starting RT, the starting RCB, the starting LDE, and getting rid of such guys as Meriweather, Taylor Price, Sanders, etc has been an impressive feat. He has also managed the situation of very key players such as losing Chung, Spikes, Fletcher for long 1/2 season stretches this yr.

---The DL has been outstanding, and he completely retooled and improved the secondary, which still has problems but has drastically improved by moving around players, and getting the most from a lesser talented group than most of the 32 NFL teams. (there were plenty of times this yr that many wondered if this was our worst 'talented' group of secondary players ever)

---getting the most from the positions

All of the following have been just fine, if not better than the 2010 versions, and certainly the 2009 versions:

(OL, TE, WR (Branch has been effective and had a fine yr, coupled with Welker), DL, LB, ST)

---getting the team to believe in itself, and show non-stop commitment

I don't remember another yr's team who had the guts to come back from several majory deficits in the same yr

---The utilization of the UDFA's

With 1/3+ of the overall roster and 8 starters as UDFA's, this has certainly been impressive

---One of the better ST units in the entire league

With all of these focuses on key areas, I would certainly say that another win on Sunday will put him as the best coaching year in his career. Another loss however, and many people unfortunately lose a lot of these feelings. A loss Sunday, and his great 2011 campaign goes unnoticed by many.

 

[patsfan13]

This one of his worst imo.
.

Well this demonstrates that your opinion isn't worth a whole lot.

 

[supafly]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

Yeah it's awfully hard to say that when the team has gone 15-3 this year and are in the Super Bowl again...

 

[coolguy]

Well this demonstrates that your opinion isn't worth a whole lot.

In terms of what his specialty is ,,,,WHICH IS DEFENSE!!

Brady anger in that redskins game sums up how he felt this season.

 

[Sparetire]

Well this demonstrates that your opinion isn't worth a whole lot.

Who are you to say such a thing? we were asked if we think that this years team is BB's finest coaching job, i didnt know the answer was yes cause its an axiom.

i sure dont think its his best cause although our D saved our ars, we dont need to foget the entire season when our D was not good at all, and thats what BB does best - building Defense. but i think due to the lockout and the tremendous activity in FA i wouldnt call it the worst one.

i think he could have done alot better but i suffer from Perfectionism so...

P.S - This forum sometimes suffer from not respecting other ppls opinions and ideas, so what if someone dosnt think like you do? jeeeez.

 

[supafly]

In terms of what his specialty is ,,,,WHICH IS DEFENSE!!

Brady anger in that redskins game sums up how he felt this season.

The offense has been superior to almost any offense in the league, while the defense has been middle of the road.

This is the opposite of 2001 when the defense carried the team, but the offense was scoring about 20 pts a game.

Either way, when you are 15-3 and have done enough of a job to gain a SB berth it's pretty impressive on any level.

I think the defense will continue to grow through another period of free agency + the draft, a full off-season, and one more yr of experience for some key players who are still young. Also keep in mind that we've yet to have the opportunity to utilize such players who had injuries problems this yr in Ras-I-Dowling, and Shane Vereen.

The defense is not as far away from where you want it to be than you think it is. Imagine another yr from Sterling Moore, Arrington, McCourty, with Dowling entering the mix + a good chance of a free agent addition. Imagine a blue chip draft choice at safety, while Chung gets another yr under his belt. The LB core has improved tremendously, and we still need that ONE huge young future player at DE/OLB to continue to move ahead. (not 'needed' but would be nice)

They will be right back in the top 10 scoring defense next yr, and will be more middle of the pack in yds allowed. No doubt.

 

[ahmed]

Nothing will ever beat 2001; if nothing else it's because he basically had a rookie 6th rounder as a QB. Now that Brady is Brady, the Patriots always have a huge advantage, no matter how crappy some parts of the team may be.

The other thing is other than the monster offense, we have some pretty good defensive players. It's just that some of them have been injured a lot.

 

[convertedpatsfan]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

:wha:

This is borderline trollish.

I don't think it's his finest coaching job, but I can't imagine anyone (except you) claiming any season for any coach that ends at the Superbowl as one of their worst jobs.

You can disagree with the OP without being absolutely ridiculous. Or are you auditioning for Skip Bayless's job?

 

[coolguy]

:wha:

This is borderline trollish.

I don't think it's his finest coaching job, but I can't imagine anyone (except you) claiming any season for any coach that ends at the Superbowl as one of their worst jobs.

You can disagree with the OP without being absolutely ridiculous. Or are you auditioning for Skip Bayless's job?

Like i said before, it's the worst defensive coaching bill has ever had.

Bill has certain standards that he must live up to, just like how a great tebow game would be mediocre by brady standards.

Is this not the worst defense bill has ever had?

 

[Lifer]

This one of his worst imo.

I think everyone here would feel a lot better going into the superbowl if the pats had a reliable defense instead of this bend but don't break one.

Are you 17 or something? They're in the Super Bowl. That isn't an easy thing to do in the NFL.

 

[PATSYLICIOUS]

I don't think he can ever top 2001 no matter what he does. That team, much as I love them, truly had no business winning a title with an offense like that. The defense was good but talentwise it's not a 'shutdown' defense you'd expect to carry us past 3 playoff opponents especially the greatest show on turf.