is Shaun Ellis better then Ty Warren IMO no not at this point in he's career he's 4 years older i think think he's noting more then dept if he makes the team but he can play 4-3 DE Ty Warren would be a DT in a 4-3 and he's not going to be better then Wilfork or Haynesworth,
for me the big story is are the young guys just not showing a nuff in TC that they are bring in washed up guys like Andre Carter and Ellis ?
With all respect pf1982, I think that every years' team is different in many ways. We have seen the other recent SB teams use veteran presence here, particularly on the D-line.
I think we all wanted some decent signings for depth, experience, and added competition; and that's exactly what we got. The additions to the defensive line are well noted--and I don't believe (or worry) that they're "washed up guys," as you say. Unless you think that they're here for the future of the team, why would it matter if they only have a couple yrs left?? They are here to help IMMEDIATELY---and that's exactly what everyone wanted!! How many times have we all heard the tired old theory of the closing window on Brady's career, and that we need to do something to win NOW??
In this modern era of free agency and especially
this yr, where we had a decreased salary cap and almost no off-season activities, the smarter teams will have to be creative in their team moves regarding personnel. That's what these signings give us..vet presence and depth in an area where we certainly needed it most last January--at a very reasonable and lower cost.
It's almost brilliant if you ask me, but of course that's just my opinion. The bottom line is that they certainly can't
hurt the team, that's for sure. The defense may have been too young and green still, and this gives them the youth for the future still, while creating balance and experience for right
now.