upstater1
Hall of Fame Poster
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2005
- Messages
- 26,466
- Reaction score
- 16,659
Re: Vick Stirs Debate in the M.V.P. Vote
I'm pretty sure Brady isn't getting caught up in this but I will tell you that enough fans or commentators have truly appreciated what Brady did in Chicago last week. **** leBeau hit the nail on the head.
Brady's performance was unbelievable.
Rhoden's argument that Vick is multidimensional is easy to refute in one sense.
Which would be easier to replicate, Vick's performance against the Giants or Brady's performance against the Bears? I'm not talking about Vick or Brady replicating their performances, but in general, which had a greater degree of difficulty? A guy like Vince Young or heck, maybe Cam Newton could do what Vick did (though Vick has been more consistent this year than Young ever will be) but how many QBs could replicate what Brady did? I'm struggling here. Maybe Peyton Manning, maybe Brees, maybe Favre but that's it.
I'm pretty sure Brady isn't getting caught up in this but I will tell you that enough fans or commentators have truly appreciated what Brady did in Chicago last week. **** leBeau hit the nail on the head.
Brady's performance was unbelievable.
Rhoden's argument that Vick is multidimensional is easy to refute in one sense.
Which would be easier to replicate, Vick's performance against the Giants or Brady's performance against the Bears? I'm not talking about Vick or Brady replicating their performances, but in general, which had a greater degree of difficulty? A guy like Vince Young or heck, maybe Cam Newton could do what Vick did (though Vick has been more consistent this year than Young ever will be) but how many QBs could replicate what Brady did? I'm struggling here. Maybe Peyton Manning, maybe Brees, maybe Favre but that's it.