Help Me Evaluate This Trade

[the wrothbroughterer]

My buddy offered me a trade in this league we're in together.

To Me (Pick Six Peyton):

Wes Welker​

Brandon Jackson​

To My Buddy (Laser Show):

Frank Gore​

I shot that down real quick but would like to upgrade my WRs. Before I get into it though, here's a quick breakdown of the league we're playing in.

10 teams starting the following positions:
QB
WR
WR
RB
RB
TE
W/R/T
W/R/T
K
DEF
8 player bench

[B][U]Pick Six Peyton[/U][/B]
QB[INDENT]Eli Manning[/INDENT]
WR1[INDENT]Roddy White[/INDENT]
WR2[INDENT]Marques Colston[/INDENT]
RB1[INDENT]Frank Gore[/INDENT]
RB2[INDENT]Jamaal Charles[/INDENT]
TE[INDENT]Antonio Gates[/INDENT]
W/R/T1[INDENT]Vernon Davis[/INDENT]
W/R/T2[INDENT]Tim Hightower[/INDENT]
K[INDENT]Rob Bironas[/INDENT]
DEF[INDENT]NY Giants[/INDENT]

[B]Bench:[/B]
Justin Forsett
Mike Wallace
Jeremy Maclin
Carnell Williams
Devin Aromashodu
Mario Manningham
Kansas City Def
Cincinatti Def

[B][U]Laser Show[/U][/B]
QB[INDENT]Drew Brees[/INDENT]
WR1[INDENT]Greg Jennings[/INDENT]
WR2[INDENT]Steve Smith[/INDENT]
RB1[INDENT]Ahmad Bradshaw[/INDENT]
RB2[INDENT]Mike Tolbert[/INDENT]
TE[INDENT]Zach Miller[/INDENT]
W/R/T1[INDENT]Wes Welker[/INDENT]
W/R/T2[INDENT]Mike Sims-Walker[/INDENT]
K[INDENT]Ryan Longwell[/INDENT]
DEF[INDENT]Philadelphia[/INDENT]

[B]Bench:[/B]
Ronnie Brown
Ryan Matthews
Brandon Jackson
Ladanian Tomlinson
Ben Roethlisberger
Jacoby Jones
Fred Taylor
Demaryius Thomas

The trade I want to offer him is the following

To Laser Show:

Steve Smith (CAR)​

Wes Welker​

Brandon Jackson​

To Pick Six Peyton:

Jamaal Charles​

Vernon Davis​

Jeremy Maclin​

Does this seem like a good trade for me to offer? It seems pretty fair and somehow Brent Celek ended up on the waiver wire. I put a claim in for him and if he ends up on my team I could really get over losing Vernon Davis really quickly. What do PatsFans?

 

[Patriot Missile]

My buddy offered me a trade in this league we're in together.

To Me (Pick Six Peyton):

Wes Welker​

Brandon Jackson​

To My Buddy (Laser Show):

Frank Gore​

I shot that down real quick but would like to upgrade my WRs. Before I get into it though, here's a quick breakdown of the league we're playing in.

10 teams starting the following positions:
QB
WR
WR
RB
RB
TE
W/R/T
W/R/T
K
DEF
8 player bench

[B][U]Pick Six Peyton[/U][/B]
QB[INDENT]Eli Manning[/INDENT]
WR1[INDENT]Roddy White[/INDENT]
WR2[INDENT]Marques Colston[/INDENT]
RB1[INDENT]Frank Gore[/INDENT]
RB2[INDENT]Jamaal Charles[/INDENT]
TE[INDENT]Antonio Gates[/INDENT]
W/R/T1[INDENT]Vernon Davis[/INDENT]
W/R/T2[INDENT]Tim Hightower[/INDENT]
K[INDENT]Rob Bironas[/INDENT]
DEF[INDENT]NY Giants[/INDENT]

[B]Bench:[/B]
Justin Forsett
Mike Wallace
Jeremy Maclin
Carnell Williams
Devin Aromashodu
Mario Manningham
Kansas City Def
Cincinatti Def

[B][U]Laser Show[/U][/B]
QB[INDENT]Drew Brees[/INDENT]
WR1[INDENT]Greg Jennings[/INDENT]
WR2[INDENT]Steve Smith[/INDENT]
RB1[INDENT]Ahmad Bradshaw[/INDENT]
RB2[INDENT]Mike Tolbert[/INDENT]
TE[INDENT]Zach Miller[/INDENT]
W/R/T1[INDENT]Wes Welker[/INDENT]
W/R/T2[INDENT]Mike Sims-Walker[/INDENT]
K[INDENT]Ryan Longwell[/INDENT]
DEF[INDENT]Philadelphia[/INDENT]

[B]Bench:[/B]
Ronnie Brown
Ryan Matthews
Brandon Jackson
Ladanian Tomlinson
Ben Roethlisberger
Jacoby Jones
Fred Taylor
Demaryius Thomas

The trade I want to offer him is the following

To Laser Show:

Steve Smith (CAR)​

Wes Welker​

Brandon Jackson​

To Pick Six Peyton:

Jamaal Charles​

Vernon Davis​

Jeremy Maclin​

Does this seem like a good trade for me to offer? It seems pretty fair and somehow Brent Celek ended up on the waiver wire. I put a claim in for him and if he ends up on my team I could really get over losing Vernon Davis really quickly. What do PatsFans?

He would have to be a fool to do that trade. It's clear at best Charles will be splitting carries with Jones which makes him useless unless Jones gets hurt. Clearly not doable.

 

[bakes781]

I completely disagree especially if this is a PPR league.

Welker is great, but you're giving up Vick's favorite target, Alex Smith's favorite target along with Charles who is like a mini CJ. Steve Smith is useless w/o a decent QB and Jackson is hardly worth starting.

You look pretty solid at WR anyway. If I were you I'd be looking to upgrade at QB. Eli scares me come December in that Jersey cold air.

I'm looking to deal Michael Vick while he's hot.

I offered this:

Vick and Cotchery

for

Ryan Mathews and Alex Smith

 

[37Harrison]

I wouldn't do this deal. As stated Charles is splitting carries with Thomas, Hightower is splitting carries with Wells. Brandon Jackson isn't doing squat with GB and is splitting carries with the other guy there. Cadillac isn't doing anything and is splitting carries with Graham and their rookie RB.

Mike Wallace is coing along nicely, Roddy White has been a beast and will continue to get the majority of the looks from Ryan, Davis and Gore are clearly the two that make the offense go in SF, Gates is the man in SD, and Colston is always a great WR to have on your roster.

I think that you need to keep what you got unless someone offers you something good at QB. BTW, why do you only have one QB?

 

[37Harrison]

I completely disagree especially if this is a PPR league.

Welker is great, but you're giving up Vick's favorite target, Alex Smith's favorite target along with Charles who is like a mini CJ. Steve Smith is useless w/o a decent QB and Jackson is hardly worth starting.

You look pretty solid at WR anyway. If I were you I'd be looking to upgrade at QB. Eli scares me come December in that Jersey cold air.

I'm looking to deal Michael Vick while he's hot.

I offered this:

Vick and Cotchery

for

Ryan Mathews and Alex Smith

You shouldn't play anymore. Seriously, Vick is ridiculous and while I know that it's a little scary with him not knowing if he's going to keep the starter position, he has done nothing to warrant that he won't. Ryan Matthews hasn't impressed me a bit this year and Alex Smith is a JAG at best.

You should be able to get something MUCH better than Alex Smith and Matthews for Vick and Cotchery.

Why not hold on to Vick and reap the rewards now? How's the rest of your team?

 

[bakes781]

well I'm 3-0 and a close 2nd in total points in my 14 team league so I think I'm doing ok. lol

Here's my roster:

QB- Cutler, Vick
RB- Forte, Charles, Wells, Donald Brown
WR- Randy Moss, Roddy White, Demaryius Thomas, Cotchery
TE- Owen Daniels, Zach Miller
K- Rackers
D/ST- Eagles

 

[Tucker]

for Vick you should get something better than an injured and underperforming Mathews and Smith.

Vick is top 5 in scoring in my league

 

[bakes781]

doesnt look like I mad a bad trade now lol