OT: Schefter reports Colts Freeney torn ligament in ankle

[PATSYLICIOUS]

Huge loss, but I'm still uneasy about Manning vs that Saints defense

 

[Disco Volante]

Yeah, but don't forget - if the Colts lose, no matter how many points they scored, it's because Manning choked....

Uh, when has Peyton Manning ever been accused of choking when it wasn't deserving?

 

[Teenuh]

Uh, when has Peyton Manning ever been accused of choking when it wasn't deserving?

My personal favorite Manning post-season choke was when he played the Pats back in 2004 and threw 4 interceptions (almost had 5) in a Pats win.

You can't really sack Manning but he can definitely be pressured into making bad passes.

 

[Tunescribe]

It's about time the Colts faced some adversity. Boo hoo for them.

 

[Fball]

Uh, when has Peyton Manning ever been accused of choking when it wasn't deserving?

I just think the "choke" label is over-used, in general. Sometimes, a defense is just better.

Is Tom Brady a "choker" now, because he wilted against Baltimore's defense, or failed to come through in the SB of '07 (and yes - 14 pts. is not coming through), or ended the 2 playoff appearances prior to that with INT's?

I would never argue that; Brady is not a choker. He's had bad games, and good games. By that same standard, I think anyone would be hard-pressed to call Manning a "choker" at this point...

 

[Teenuh]

I just think the "choke" label is over-used, in general. Sometimes, a defense is just better.

Is Tom Brady a "choker" now, because he wilted against Baltimore's defense, or failed to come through in the SB of '07 (and yes - 14 pts. is not coming through), or ended the 2 playoff appearances prior to that with INT's?

I would never argue that; Brady is not a choker. He's had bad games, and good games. By that same standard, I think anyone would be hard-pressed to call Manning a "choker" at this point...

The problem is that Brady's success rate is much higher than his "choking" moments. Manning seems to always have problems in the post season. So far he hasn't had any major issues this year but I have a feeling that will change next week with the way the Saints are playing defense. If they can get at manning like they did with favre, he'll throw some bad passes.

 

[Deus Irae]

I just think the "choke" label is over-used, in general. Sometimes, a defense is just better.

Is Tom Brady a "choker" now, because he wilted against Baltimore's defense, or failed to come through in the SB of '07 (and yes - 14 pts. is not coming through), or ended the 2 playoff appearances prior to that with INT's?

I would never argue that; Brady is not a choker. He's had bad games, and good games. By that same standard, I think anyone would be hard-pressed to call Manning a "choker" at this point...

Manning is a choker. He may be the biggest choker in the history of the NFL.

If it weren't for the Patriots having much of their defense sidelined in the second half of the 2006 AFCCG, Manning wouldn't have any Super Bowl rings, and he would be the unquestioned king of the gas pipe.

 

[Fball]

Manning is a choker. He may be the biggest choker in the history of the NFL.

If it weren't for the Patriots having much of their defense sidelined in the second half of the 2006 AFCCG, Manning wouldn't have any Super Bowl rings, and he would be the unquestioned king of the gas pipe.

Excuses, excuses, excuses. Manning led an incredible comeback, with a huge monkey on his back against his biggest rival.

If it hadn't been for the tuck rule, Martz forgetting the offensive gameplan, the Carolina kicker shanking it, McNabb getting sick, etc, etc.

And how have Brady's last 5 years been? The 2007 SB was arguably the biggest single-team choke in football history (and he was QB, btw)

 

[jmt57]

I just think the "choke" label is over-used, in general.

I completely agree. The concept of 'choke' is that you can't breath; that is, you couldn't handle the pressure, tensed up and folded in a high pressure situation.

Somehow over the years it has transformed into a derisive term aimed at humiliating anybody that lost a big game, especially championship games. The reality is that for every winner in those games there also has to be a team that loses. I've just never followed the logic that a team that lost choked; losing and choking are two completely different things, in my opinion.

 

[Koma]

Freeney injured himself with just over 2 minutes to go in a 30-17 game. The Jets offense had been shut out in the second half.

When are the Colts going to learn to pull key players late in games that are effectively over?

 

[BostonPatriot]

Excuses, excuses, excuses. Manning led an incredible comeback, with a huge monkey on his back against his biggest rival.

If it hadn't been for the tuck rule, Martz forgetting the offensive gameplan, the Carolina kicker shanking it, McNabb getting sick, etc, etc.

And how have Brady's last 5 years been? The 2007 SB was arguably the biggest single-team choke in football history (and he was QB, btw)

Don't even bother with posters like Dues and DaBruinz. Both are narcissits, who think they know everything. Anyone with a brain knows that Manning is not a choker.

You hit the nail on the head with your points about the tuck rule and such.

 

[WhiZa]

Where have we seen this before? Then he'll come out of nowhere and have a monster game.

 

[jmt57]

Excuses, excuses, excuses. Manning led an incredible comeback, with a huge monkey on his back against his biggest rival.

True. Law of averages says it was about time - aided by the flu sweeping through the Pats locker room and a bad flag for a rule that had been changed (face-guarding.) Regardless, congrats to Manning and the Colts for that win.

If it hadn't been for the tuck rule, Martz forgetting the offensive gameplan, the Carolina kicker shanking it, McNabb getting sick, etc, etc.

And I could easily go through an equal number of 'if not for this one play' going the other way over the years that would have resulted in more Pats' championships; that argument is ridiculous.

And how have Brady's last 5 years been?

Not too bad. Here's some of what happened in his last five season in which he played at least one full quarter. Led the league in passing yards twice. Set an NFL record for most TD passes in a season. Double-digit wins every year. The NFL's only 16-0 season. Two AFC championships and one Super Bowl victory.

The 2007 SB was arguably the biggest single-team choke in football history (and he was QB, btw)

Wait, if I recall you just said the word choke was over-used. In case you've forgotten, Brady led the team to what would have been a come from behind game-winning drive with two minutes left. But I guess it's not only Brady's fault that Asante Samuel dropped an interception, and the d-line let Eli escape their grasp, but that he also choked in doing so.

In other words, in your view it's okay to label players and other teams chokers, but forbidden to label players and the team that you are a fan of chokers. Can you say hypocrite?

 

[juny]

I'm guessing the line for the over/under went up a few points.

If this report is true, then the Colts secondary is going to get exposed. I think both teams are going to score over 30.

Go Saints!

 

[patsinthesnow]

Its pretty pathetic when instead of talking on your own message boards (where your team is playing in the SUPERBOWL next week).you colts fans would rather ***** about Manning a pats board.

Jealousy.

 

[BostonPatriot]

True. Law of averages says it was about time - aided by the flu sweeping through the Pats locker room and a bad flag for a rule that had been changed (face-guarding.) Regardless, congrats to Manning and the Colts for that win.

And I could easily go through an equal number of 'if not for this one play' going the other way over the years that would have resulted in more Pats' championships; that argument is ridiculous.

Not too bad. Here's some of what happened in his last five season in which he played at least one full quarter. Led the league in passing yards twice. Set an NFL record for most TD passes in a season. Double-digit wins every year. The NFL's only 16-0 season. Two AFC championships and one Super Bowl victory.


Wait, if I recall you just said the word choke was over-used. In case you've forgotten, Brady led the team to what would have been a come from behind game-winning drive with two minutes left. But I guess it's not only Brady's fault that Asante Samuel dropped an interception, and the d-line let Eli escape their grasp, but that he also choked in doing so.

In other words, in your view it's okay to label players and other teams chokers, but forbidden to label players and the team that you are a fan of chokers. Can you say hypocrite?

Funny how you say this:
And I could easily go through an equal number of 'if not for this one play' going the other way over the years that would have resulted in more Pats' championships; that argument is ridiculous.

After you said this:
True. Law of averages says it was about time - aided by the flu sweeping through the Pats locker room and a bad flag for a rule that had been changed (face-guarding.) Regardless, congrats to Manning and the Colts for that win.

Why must you try and discredit Manning to the point where you look foolish? The guy is one of the greatest qb's ever, and even if you don't think he's as good as Brady (which is rediculous) How much worse is he? 1% - 2%?

 

[BostonPatriot]

Its pretty pathetic when instead of talking on your own message boards (where your team is playing in the SUPERBOWL next week).you colts fans would rather ***** about Manning a pats board.

Jealousy.

Are you saying that if roles were reversed, there wouldn't be Pats fans over at the colts board defending Brady? I can think of two threads off the top of my head that called for Pats fan to particpate in Brady vs Manning debates on the Colts board. Do a search.

 

[jmt57]

Funny how you say this:
And I could easily go through an equal number of 'if not for this one play' going the other way over the years that would have resulted in more Pats' championships; that argument is ridiculous.

After you said this:
True. Law of averages says it was about time - aided by the flu sweeping through the Pats locker room and a bad flag for a rule that had been changed (face-guarding.) Regardless, congrats to Manning and the Colts for that win.
Why must you try and discredit Manning to the point where you look foolish? The guy is one of the greatest qb's ever, and even if you don't think he's as good as Brady (which is rediculous) How much worse is he? 1% - 2%?

Easy. It's two different responses to two different comments. The first comment was in response to what FBall said about essentially discrediting each of the Patriots' championships. The other comment was in response to the 'excuses, excuses' comment from a Colts' fan who felt it necessary to visit a fan forum and dog that team and their quarterback.

Exactly where did I discredit Manning? Did I say even one disparing word about him? No, because I think he's one of the greatest quarterbacks in the history of the NFL.

Now, in the name of truth in advertising, don't you think you might want to consider changing your name from BostonPatriot to IndianapolisColt?

 

[jmt57]

Its pretty pathetic when instead of talking on your own message boards (where your team is playing in the SUPERBOWL next week).you colts fans would rather ***** about Manning a pats board.

Jealousy.

That pretty much nails it. With apologies to the two very cool Steeler fans who often visit and comment, I thought Pittsburgh fans as a whole had the biggest levels of insecurity, inferiority complexes and obsession with the Pats. Apparently Colt fans are right up there too.

 

[wiggins!]

UPDATE.....

Colts change their wording of injury....calling it a third degree low basketball sprain.....

Status still remains questionable.