Brady vs. Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

[Phokus]

Manning vs. Brady | IndyStar.com | The Indianapolis Star

you know who to vote for

edit: oops, there's another thread on that

OH BY THE WAY, YOU CAN VOTE EVERY 30 MINUTES

 

[Palm Beach Pats Fan]

vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

IndyStar has a stats breakdown and online poll over "which QB would you rather have"

Now it is 54%-46% Manning, amazingly close considering the site is the Indianapolis newspaper

It would be funny to see Tom win the poll.

Manning vs. Brady | IndyStar.com | The Indianapolis Star

vote early, vote often (every 30 minutes)

 

[PatsFanSince74]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

Thanks!!!

Vote early

Vote often (OP says it's OK every 30 mins, so I believe him and will set my alarm as I work today to remind me)

Bump frequently

 

[Kontradiction]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

Nice. The balance isn't as overwhelmingly in favor for Manning as it was yesterday.

 

[Kontradiction]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

*Tries to merge, but cannot*

 

[ALP]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

u know, even at indy star, since they included PLAYOFF stats, its a no brainer

if the postseason stats werent there, i could see an argument....with them there.....there is NO argument, lol

 

[MoLewisrocks]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

Indy Star is actually a pats fan troll takeover site. We're lucky as you goad Colts and other teams fans here that Ian doesn't allow something like that to happen here...

 

[Joker]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

They used to ban ANY Pats fan that posted there back in the day...IndyColt 1, 2, 3, 4, ad infinitum must have died and left the place rudderless

 

[Phokus]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

guys, lets keep this thread up all week so brady wins, that would be hilarious

 

[JohnVM]

re: Brady vs Manning (merged) Comparison Thread

51 to 49 now keep the votes goin woo

 

[juxtapoz15]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

Thanks!!!

Vote early

Vote often (OP says it's OK every 30 mins, so I believe him and will set my alarm as I work today to remind me)

Bump frequently

To the other IT folks out there:
I'm wondering how they determine that 30 minute timer? Probably by recording MAC (physical) address of network card and IP address. You could easily change either of these and vote as often as you want. Even better someone that knows how to program better than me could create a script or bot to do this for you every second and vote. Just a thought....

 

[MoLewisrocks]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

To the other IT folks out there:
I'm wondering how they determine that 30 minute timer? Probably by recording MAC (physical) address of network card and IP address. You could easily change either of these and vote as often as you want. Even better someone that knows how to program better than me could create a script or bot to do this for you every second and vote. Just a thought....

That would be great. Then maybe someone from Indy would decide to retaliate and knock this place off the map for a couple days...

Honestly, wish some of you children would just go back to the smack talking idiotic ESPN boards where you belong.

 

[Phokus]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

To the other IT folks out there:
I'm wondering how they determine that 30 minute timer? Probably by recording MAC (physical) address of network card and IP address. You could easily change either of these and vote as often as you want. Even better someone that knows how to program better than me could create a script or bot to do this for you every second and vote. Just a thought....

Yeah don't give them a reason to discount NE votes. We will win by sheer numbers alone

 

[skri65]

In What Ways is Peyton Manning a Better QB than Brady: The Ultimate Homer Test

I can't tell if I'm actually eager to read responses, or if I am simply eager to perform a social experiment on Homerism.

Ok guys, here's the deal. First off, I admit fully that this may not be the week to post this thread. My apologies if this angers anyone. Especially those who want to believe we're gonna light it up in Indy. I for one DO think we are going to win, although we are goign to need to bring our A game.

BUT

There's been a million threads on Brady Vs. Mannings, and who is better. I'm NOT IN ANY WAY ASKING that. I am not asking who is better. I am simply asking even the biggest Brady fans (of which I consider us all) to concede a single way in which Peyton Manning is a better Quarterback than Brady.

To clarify, I just want to hear from anyone willing to offer just one part of Peyton Mannings game that is better than Bradys. I don't want to hear about why Brady is better, nor do I want this to devolve into a thread about who is the better QB. I just want to see if anyone can get past their homerism for even a minute and search for a single part of Peyton's game that could be better than Bradys.

So, let's hear it. Obviously, I'd prefer it if the trolls stayed out of this one. Is anyone able to look at the two completely objectively?

EDIT: I figure the Colts fans are going to respond anyway, so for them, I simply ask in what ways Brady is a better QB than Peyton?

Rules of the game: Patriot fans can't say ways Brady is better, and Colts fans can't say about ways Peyton is better. It has to be the opposite. In what ways is your nemesis better than your hero. This seems like a very evil question to ask..that is, if anyone is willing to respond.

 

[PatsFanSince74]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

To the other IT folks out there:
I'm wondering how they determine that 30 minute timer? Probably by recording MAC (physical) address of network card and IP address. You could easily change either of these and vote as often as you want. Even better someone that knows how to program better than me could create a script or bot to do this for you every second and vote. Just a thought....

let's not get greedy...just vote every 30 minutes if you're at your desk so they can't say someone tried to win by hacking...

Tommy's now within 100 votes...

 

[PatsFanSince74]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

Yeah don't give them a reason to discount NE votes. We will win by sheer numbers alone

absolutely...let's not wreck this...we can win just by voting according to their own rules....

 

[JSn]

Re: In What Ways is Peyton Manning a Better QB than Brady: The Ultimate Homer Test

3 Super Bowl Rings with Shoddy Receivers, 7 wins in the last ten times facing each other.

 

[DarrylS]

Re: In What Ways is Peyton Manning a Better QB than Brady: The Ultimate Homer Test

3 Super Bowl Rings with Shoddy Receivers, 7 wins in the last ten times facing each other.

Less is more... well said.

 

[skri65]

Re: In What Ways is Peyton Manning a Better QB than Brady: The Ultimate Homer Test

3 Super Bowl Rings with Shoddy Receivers, 7 wins in the last ten times facing each other.

Intentional misunderstanding of the question?

 

[WeLovethePats!]

Re: vote for Brady over Manning, "which QB would you rather have"

hehehe... i just tied it!