Chiefs fans debate trading 3rd pick overall for Matt Cassel

[Lifer]

Chiefs Babb – Trade 3rd for Cassel - ChiefsPlanet

 

[nashvillepatsfan]

Mods. We already have this discussion


http://www.patsfans.com/new-england...star-sports-blog-calling-team-get-cassel.html

 

[ScottieC]

Mods. We already have this discussion


http://www.patsfans.com/new-england...star-sports-blog-calling-team-get-cassel.html

Well, one is a blog and the other is a discussion on their Message Board like ours - So technically they are different.

I enjoyed reading some of the posts - Seems like the majority is in the "Hell NO" camp as to trading the 3rd pick for The Cassel.

 

[FortressX]

The people over there seem to hate Matt.
I can understand their reluctance about trading the 3rd overall pick, but when I read people saying they wouldn't give up a 3rd round pick for Matt they lose me.

 

[ALP]

Well, one is a blog and the other is a discussion on their Message Board like ours - So technically they are different.

I enjoyed reading some of the posts - Seems like the majority is in the "Hell NO" camp as to trading the 3rd pick for The Cassel.

LOL, man those guys are greedy...

when was the last time they ahd a QB anyway...it almost sounds as if they have HOF waiting if they dont get one soon...LOL

 

[DarrylS]

Not quite sure this team would want a 3rd...

 

[Kontradiction]

So they are hoping to surround the Cassel with a third overall? That would be great for us but we all know Pioli is no idiot. Could we get a first rounder for Cassel? Probably. But not that high of a first round pick.

 

[DNR]

The people over there seem to hate Matt.
I can understand their reluctance about trading the 3rd overall pick, but when I read people saying they wouldn't give up a 3rd round pick for Matt they lose me.

Same here...can't quite grasp that mentality

 

[Rob0729]

If I was a Chiefs' fan, I wouldn't be all that psyched about keeping the 3rd pick. It is a bit of crap shoot and an expensive one at that. At least with Cassel, Pioli knows what he is getting. Here are some stellar top 5 picks in recent years:

2003
Charles Rogers (2nd)
Dewayne Robertson (4th)

2004
Robert Gallery (2nd)

2005
Alex Smith (1st)
Ronnie Brown (2nd) Not a bust, but nowhere good enough to be the second pick in the draft
Braylon Edwards (3rd) Ditto
Cedric Benson (4th)
Cadillac Williams (5th)
O for 5 in that draft in getting a franchise player.

2006
Vince Young (3rd)
D'Brickishaw Ferguson (4th)

2007
JaMarcus Russell (1st)

2008
Too early to tell, but Glenn Dorsey and Darren McFadden were really disapointing this season. Vernon Gholston at 6 has been a disaster so far.

So even if Cassel doesn't build on this year, he may be a safer bet than you get with the third pick.

Granted I agree that I don't think Belichick wants the third pick and would rather get subsequent picks equalling the value of the third pick. It is too hard to trade out of the top 5 and too expensive to sign a top 5 draft pick who is a crap shoot.

 

[Lifer]

I doubt Pioli, having learned a thing or two about the draft, will keep that #3 overall.

People out here will moan and groan and not understand it, but i wouldnt be surprised to see him trade it down for #2 and #3 and a #1 in 2010 or something and then sign a Garcia-caliber QB. That would give the Chiefs picks #35, a 40-something, #67, and,say #80. with Pioli doing the picking thats a lot of quality.

thats what always happens here.

 

[JoePats]

I doubt Pioli, having learned a thing or two about the draft, will keep that #3 overall.

Everyone said the same thing about Parcells last year. I don't doubt Parcells tried to trade the pick but you have to find a dance partner.

 

[Fencer]

Here's one way that it the fact that it's Pioli could help. He could make a last minute trade-down to, say, somewhere in the 7-10 range, then turn around and flip the new pick to us for Cassell -- IF he had already come to a suitable agreement w/ Cassell about a new contract (or if he were comfortable taking on the one-year franchise deal).

However, that scenario requires a lot of communication and trust between the Chiefs, the Pats, and Cassell's camp.

 

[mcsully]

Mods. We already have this discussion


http://www.patsfans.com/new-england...star-sports-blog-calling-team-get-cassel.html

Stop the insanity with the mod crap.. To many times I'm reading one thing and just because someone mention something about another thread or another team its moved.. This is the only forum I come to that reorganizes threads this much..

 

[WhiZa]

For the Chiefs it doesn't make sense. Thigpen may not be as good as Cassel, but he's serviceable. If you get rid of the #3 you're losing out on upgrading another position.

I'm thinking Pioli draft lineman in the first round. The same way the pats started building their team.

 

[brdmaverick]

The people over there seem to hate Matt.
I can understand their reluctance about trading the 3rd overall pick, but when I read people saying they wouldn't give up a 3rd round pick for Matt they lose me.

It's funny that this is even a discussion. To think that during the preseason many here wanted him cut.

 

[Bobs My Uncle]

I wonder if the question was posed differently - say "if the Chiefs were going to spend the 3rd overall on a rookie QB would you rather they trade that pick for Matt Cassel instead" - would the readers opinions change?

 

[AzPatsFan]

If I was a Chiefs' fan, I wouldn't be all that psyched about keeping the 3rd pick. It is a bit of crap shoot and an expensive one at that. At least with Cassel, Pioli knows what he is getting. Here are some stellar top 5 picks in recent years:

2003
Charles Rogers (2nd)
Dewayne Robertson (4th)

2004
Robert Gallery (2nd)

2005
Alex Smith (1st)
Ronnie Brown (2nd) Not a bust, but nowhere good enough to be the second pick in the draft
Braylon Edwards (3rd) Ditto
Cedric Benson (4th)
Cadillac Williams (5th)
O for 5 in that draft in getting a franchise player.

2006
Vince Young (3rd)
D'Brickishaw Ferguson (4th)

2007
JaMarcus Russell (1st)

2008
Too early to tell, but Glenn Dorsey and Darren McFadden were really disapointing this season. Vernon Gholston at 6 has been a disaster so far.

So even if Cassel doesn't build on this year, he may be a safer bet than you get with the third pick.

Granted I agree that I don't think Belichick wants the third pick and would rather get subsequent picks equalling the value of the third pick. It is too hard to trade out of the top 5 and too expensive to sign a top 5 draft pick who is a crap shoot.

Illminating review. But it won't change the minds of the draftniks who hoard picks like Midas hoarded Gold. But I disagree with your "Its to hard to trade out of the ..." Bill had the #7 last year, and traded down to 11 or 12 and still got the DROY. And a got another draft pick.

I would think that Bill would probably move down to 7-8 and pick up a pick; if he didn't use the pick for a stud LOT; and then move down to 10-12 and pick up a stud whatever, and also get another pick. JUST LIKE HE DID LAST YEAR...

 

[Pat_the_Patriot]

I doubt Pioli, having learned a thing or two about the draft, will keep that #3 overall.

People out here will moan and groan and not understand it, but i wouldnt be surprised to see him trade it down for #2 and #3 and a #1 in 2010 or something and then sign a Garcia-caliber QB. That would give the Chiefs picks #35, a 40-something, #67, and,say #80. with Pioli doing the picking thats a lot of quality.

thats what always happens here.

I agree with your post... this IS Pioli that we're talking about.. AND, I believe that he can start negotiations with the Pats for MC with his #34 pick (yes, we can assume that the pick will only sign a 4 year deal... as opposed to a 5 year deal... BUT that pick will be a LOT cheaper than a first rounder, too... AND that pick could BE, or could be packaged to trade up for Pettigrew, which my gut (which ain't worth much, lol) tells me BB may covet strongly)... although there would have to be more to it, too... perhaps their high fourth rounder and a conditional second/third next year (depending upon team finish)?

 

[Ice Cold Bruschi]

Man I hope Pioli is dumber than they are, I agree with them it would be ******ed to trade the 3rd overall for Cassel

 

[Pat_the_Patriot]

btw: I know it's not a popular postion here.. but as much as I WISH that MC was worth a #3 draft pick in 2009, I don't believe that he is, either. Just my two pennies, though... while I hope that you all are right, I don't believe that you are... AND, thinking like a Chiefs fan, I wouldn't want to see that deal go through. THAT being said... I believe that they will offer a "flip trades" scenario with us (the #3 overall for our #23 overall) but I'm not sure what the add-ons would have to be from each side... I think that Pioli would want the boot from BB and BB would want the boot from Pioli, no? Thus that trade would go down in flames.

BTW: I don't think that BB WANTS the #3... not unless he knows that he can immead. trade down and pick up extra draft picks for it... too much $$ invested in a top 5 first rounder.

Now I've made it 3 pennies... so I'll shut up now.