No decision by Commish yet because.... - New England Patriots Forums

thunder509s · 09-13-2007, 06:27 AM

He realizes that this is a lit powderkeg and whatever decision is handed down has the potential to rock the foundations of the entire league (past, present and future.) Face it, we're not speaking of a player or players. We're speaking of an entire organization, it's ownership, players, coaches and fan base. We're speaking of an enterprise in itself! I'm confident the reason the Commish has not had any formal comment on the situation is that he is gathering as much input from intellectuals from several diffferent backgrounds on what might be the potential repercussions his final decision will have. This whole "camera-gate" is completely out of control from players to coaches to owners to investors to sponsers....the list is long. The Commish knows this. Whatever decision is handed down, will be precise and deliberate and with the best interest of keeping the integrity of the entire NFL intact.

Please post your comments on this~!

MrBigglesWorth · 09-13-2007, 06:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thunder509s

He realizes that this is a lit powderkeg and whatever decision is handed down has the potential to rock the foundations of the entire league (past, present and future.) Face it, we're not speaking of a player or players. We're speaking of an entire organization, it's ownership, players, coaches and fan base. We're speaking of an enterprise in itself! I'm confident the reason the Commish has not had any formal comment on the situation is that he is gathering as much input from intellectuals from several diffferent backgrounds on what might be the potential repercussions his final decision will have. This whole "camera-gate" is completely out of control from players to coaches to owners to investors to sponsers....the list is long. The Commish knows this. Whatever decision is handed down, will be precise and deliberate and with the best interest of keeping the integrity of the entire NFL intact.

Please post your comments on this~!

I'd agree. Time will calm this down.

Is this the Commish who write this by the way?

PatsWSB47 · 09-13-2007, 06:35 AM

I hope he's fair but I have a feeling he's going to cave in and hand down a whopper penalty. He may even go the extra mile to "prove" he's in charge. The funny thing for the other coaches and owners is that the "careful what you wish for" saying will someday soon come back and bite them in the azz. you don't think their cheating ways won't be exposed by Bill? I'm sure he has some stories to tell the Comish. If he gets evidence, he'll be forced to hand down equally harsh penalties.

naclone · 09-13-2007, 06:36 AM

I don't doubt that Goodell is genuinely pissed off. And I'm sure for the last few days he's had guys like Polian and Fisher in his ear yelling for blood. But I also think, and as we've started to hear in the media the last few days, that the voices of reason are getting to him as well. Don't underestimate his relationship with Kraft.

So we should all be grateful that they are taking their time on this and didn't do something reactionary on Monday.

I feel like we are going to made examples of and Goodell will have to SOMETHING in order to not come off like a patsie (this is where his relationship with Kraft hurts us - remember Peter King's comments when Goodell got the job?) but I don't think there will be any suspensions or high draft picks involved in the penalty.

and don't think for a minute the media firestorm wasn't orchestrated to make sure that Goodell didn't let this whole thing slide. wouldn't be at all surprised if it was Polian and his cronies on the competition committee leaking reports about Belichick going to new york and goodell being pissed, and talk of suspensions and soforth. that way if Goodell does anything short of that he comes off as being in Krafts pocket.

Patriot_in_NY · 09-13-2007, 06:44 AM

I don't think a suspension will be given. If his decision hurts the in-season ability of a potential SB, you can bet that forces will expose the whole ugly underbelly of this league, and that is something the commish does not want.

***richpats*** · 09-13-2007, 07:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Patriot_in_NY

I don't think a suspension will be given. If his decision hurts the in-season ability of a potential SB, you can bet that forces will expose the whole ugly underbelly of this league, and that is something the commish does not want.

The more and more I hear about "everybody does it", the more and more I think the NFL will do it's best to sweep this under the rug. No way will they say the Pats cheated, no way. Teams will be exposing each other left and right, and the Pats will take it out on someone else, I guarantee.

I'd like to add that I think the NFL is waiting til Friday (probably afternoon) because it will be a lighter penalty than people expect and it won't grab as much attention as it would today. They are probably aiming for the shortest timeframe between the announcement of the punishment and Sunday night's game.

upstater1 · 09-13-2007, 07:22 AM

The integrity of the NFL? What does this have to do with integrity?

Let me present an opposing view. if you read the NFL's actual prohibition against videotaping, you'll see that no mention at all is made of stealing signals. The rule only addresses making a videotape of an opposing coach's signals. Now, you and I know what the intent is, but why is the NFL hell-bent on avoiding legilsation that involves the use of stolen signals?

The NFL can't legislate this because it's such an ingrained part of the game. There is no before and after here, no "before cheating was uncovered," and no league "after cheating was uncovered." There is only an always. There always was this sort of cheating, and always will be, until they install radio receivers in defensive helmets.

Since they couldn't legislate against it, an unspoken rule developed that I'm sure everyone thought they understood. One, don't do it blatantly. Two, never make accusations of cheating like this because the NFL has no way to adjudicate the accusation without calling into question the NFL's stance on stealing signals. We're in a big gray area. Both the Patriots and the Jets have broken the spirit of the NFL's unspoken stance. The Patriots were too brazen, and the Jets were too ratfinkish. The Patriots will be punished, and they should be, but I'm sure the commissioner is right now pissed that the Jets have invited a slew of lawyers and bureaucrats into the room to look over what was previously a gentleman's agreement. We already know the NFL's true feelings on this issue because they declared the Dolphins cheating last year as valid and legal. now the Jets have forced them into a tight spot. New legislation is needed, and now we're going to endure endless Sundays of teams sicking their security and lawyers on one another.

That's what this entire event means. It has very little to do with the game, or the game's integrity. It has everything to do with people's egos, lawyers, the NFL's own screwed up organization which allows the competition committee to be composed of a few select teams that inevitably tilt the field in their own favor.

***DarrylS*** · 09-13-2007, 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PatsSB42

you don't think their cheating ways won't be exposed by Bill? I'm sure he has some stories to tell the Comish. If he gets evidence, he'll be forced to hand down equally harsh penalties.

No I don't, that is what separates him from Mangini, BB has been involved with the game too long, has too many alliances, is too well thought of when the microphones are taken away and too much smarts to just roll over on someone.. he will take his lumps and walk away as a man, as for the next time he plays the Jets he will develop a game plan that will embarass Mangini.

FirstAndGoal · 09-13-2007, 07:30 AM

The Patriots lawyer just made his case to the Commish. Here's the link.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8uCS9wcyQ4

PatsChick87 · 09-13-2007, 07:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by upstater1

The integrity of the NFL? What does this have to do with integrity?

Let me present an opposing view. if you read the NFL's actual prohibition against videotaping, you'll see that no mention at all is made of stealing signals. The rule only addresses making a videotape of an opposing coach's signals. Now, you and I know what the intent is, but why is the NFL hell-bent on avoiding legilsation that involves the use of stolen signals?

The NFL can't legislate this because it's such an ingrained part of the game. There is no before and after here, no "before cheating was uncovered," and no league "after cheating was uncovered." There is only an always. There always was this sort of cheating, and always will be, until they install radio receivers in defensive helmets.

Since they couldn't legislate against it, an unspoken rule developed that I'm sure everyone thought they understood. One, don't do it blatantly. Two, never make accusations of cheating like this because the NFL has no way to adjudicate the accusation without calling into question the NFL's stance on stealing signals. We're in a big gray area. Both the Patriots and the Jets have broken the spirit of the NFL's unspoken stance. The Patriots were too brazen, and the Jets were too ratfinkish. The Patriots will be punished, and they should be, but I'm sure the commissioner is right now pissed that the Jets have invited a slew of lawyers and bureaucrats into the room to look over what was previously a gentleman's agreement. We already know the NFL's true feelings on this issue because they declared the Dolphins cheating last year as valid and legal. now the Jets have forced them into a tight spot. New legislation is needed, and now we're going to endure endless Sundays of teams sicking their security and lawyers on one another.

That's what this entire event means. It has very little to do with the game, or the game's integrity. It has everything to do with people's egos, lawyers, the NFL's own screwed up organization which allows the competition committee to be composed of a few select teams that inevitably tilt the field in their own favor.

Great post!