skaIownsIyou

anyone else sick of the comparison of manning vs. brady?

most sports analysts are always flip flopping on who is better....2-3 years ago, 9 out of 10 analysts say brady is far better than manning....now that manning finally won a ring, 9 out of 10 say manning is the better...

i even read on an article on espn.com today, and one analyst thinks the great debate 50 years from now will be "romo or manning"

romo??? he starts off 5-1, and finishes what? 3-3? and now he's already replacing tom brady in the new millenium best qb??

wow....just wow...

think about it....

peyton was a #1 overall selection in his draft...brady was a 6th rounder...

peyton SHOULDVE already have had 3 rings, as far as expectations were concerned, but the 6th rounder brady has 3, going onto 4 this upcoming season...and peyton FINALLY won ONE, when he was 30 years old

some analysts say, well brady had a better defense during his superbowl seasons, - well thats cause brady's defense didnt use a cover 2 scheme, where you let the opposing offense catch the ball, and the defenders swarm to the player for minimal gain....

..brady had a better defense b/c the pats organization didnt put all their cap money into the offense


yes, manning has a few mvp's and some records, and other future records, but that's what you should expect when you have guys like edge james, marvin harrison, and reggie wayne for so many years,

brady had different receivers, who werent as highly touted as wayne/harrison and he's had a few runnings backs in his backfield

it just bugs me, b/c in 5 years when both manning and brady are going into retirement, 9 out of 10 analyst will be talking about how much better brady was than manning....

now lets also check the qb matchups in recent superbowls between brady and manning

2001- brady vs. warner(along with the "best show on turf"
2003- brady vs. delhomme
2004- brady vs. mcnabb

2006- manning vs. REX GROSSMAN


warner had marshall faulk in his prime, and they were the self proclaimed "best show on turf"
delhomme was an undrafted free agent, but he was no rex grossman, even last year, many people though the panthers were preseason favorites to win the 2006 superbowl, let alone make it to the superbowl
mcnabb is pretty much the "karl malone" of football...malone never won a nba title b/c he was in the michael jordan era, and mcnabb will probably never win a superbowl b/c he's in the brady/manning era......and according to that one analyst on espn.com, mcnabb wouldve been in the romo/manning era

rex grossman........enough said, its rex grossman....he openly admitted that he wasnt prepared and didnt much care for the last game of the season against the packers....that says a lot about a qb....at least in carolina(2003) and st. louis(2001) the home team werent crying for the backup qb to replace their starting qb...grossman and greise


what does everyone else think?

BB_dynasty

I completely agree. Manning has had far more talent around him, and to compare them is unfair, even though Brady is easily better. Brady hasn't had people cover up his bad passes by making amazing catches.

__________________
The patriots don't rebuild their team. They reload.



To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Nordberg

I agree 100%...but lets relax, and enjoy the upcoming season. The world will see that Brady has always been the better QB, now that he has comparable talent. They have been 1a and 1b with Brady throwing too average wideouts....and Manning throwing to two all pro's. How anyone can over look that is beyond me. Brady is going to absolutely tear up defenses this year.

I can't wait see teams $hitting there pants on Sunday's

PatsFan24

its funny when you still here people say brady is just a system qb where manning is one of the best ever. but that whole colts system is built around manning and the offense, brady has had to work with a crew if new wrs and backs. the system qb is manning, because they give him everything he needs

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


Patriots Dynasty!!!!

Super Bowl XXXVI XXXVIII XXXIX Champs

"Stats are for losers, the final score is for winners." - Bill Belichick

Crazy Patriot Guy

I saw that too and I think that just was a mistake on the reporter's part. He said Romo but instantly started talking about Brady. He said nothing else of Romo.

Sean Pa Patriot

This is another case of Mediaheads trying to hear themselves talk. Sorry to say Brady was 3 min or a first down of going to another super bowl.. It just did not work out that way..

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.



We going to take it one game at a time

Pats Fanatic

I personally love the rivalry and all the comparisons and so forth every game between them. We as New England area sports fan have not seen anything like this since Bird/ Magic and Russell / Chamberlain. We are watching something special and I am loving it.

__________________
One can only see what one observes, and one observes only things which are already in the mind -Alphonse Bertillon

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

BB_dynasty

Yea, I love to see it, and I believe Brady is the better QB, but hasn't had the weapons. Manning has had it good his whole career when it comes to his wide outs. Lets see if manning could get 2,000 yards with Caldwell and the rest of last years receiving corps. Then give Brady Peyton's targets...

__________________
The patriots don't rebuild their team. They reload.



To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

stinkypete

Read the article, in the very next line he corrects himself, and states that the debate is Manning/Brady.

It is a very poorly delivered joke.

richpats

Last season I gave up arguing b/c watching Brady throw to guys like Caldwell and Gabriel made me realize that a true comparison was impossible.

Now, after watching Manning lead the Colts to the SB, it made me realize how pointless the argument is. Who cares if Brady is better or not, I just want the ring. We can bicker when these guys are retired.